| 100% | LAHR | 4 | Bert who sang "If I Were King of the Forest" |
| 85% | LAHR | 4 | First actor who sang "If I Were King of the Forest" |
| 67% | LAHR | 4 | "If I were king of the forest ..." singer |
| 67% | LAHR | 4 | ''If I Were King of the Forest'' singer |
| 53% | LAHR | 4 | Bert who sang "If I Only Had the Nerve" |
| 49% | SASHA | 5 | One of the daughters for whom the 2010 book "Of Thee I Sing" was written |
| 46% | ERMA | 4 | Bombeck who wrote If Life Is a Bowl of Cherries, What Am I Doing in the Pits? |
| 46% | ASHE | 4 | Arthur who was king of the court? |
| 44% | TEVYE | 5 | Fiddler on the Roof character who sings "If I Were a Rich Man" |
| 44% | YOU | 3 | "Until I Found ___," 2021 song by Stephen Sanchez featuring Georgia, who is just the kind of girl they sing songs about |
| 44% | MANILOW | 7 | Barry who sings "I Write the Songs" (which was written by Bruce Johnston of the Beach Boys) |
| 44% | ODYSSEUS | 8 | King of Ithaca who was the hero of Homer's tale |
| 44% | ROBB | 4 | Stark who was King of the North in Game of Thrones |
| 44% | NEWLEY | 6 | Anthony who sang "What Kind of Fool Am I" |
| 43% | LEAR | 4 | King who was the father of Cordelia |
| 43% | STUART | 6 | James I was the first king of this royal dynasty |
| 43% | AMES | 4 | Harry of the novel "The Man Who Cried I Am" |
| 43% | BOBBYDARWIN | 11 | Singer who sang "If I Were a Giant Sea Tortoise"? |
| 43% | ONCELER | 7 | Character who sings "How Bad Can I Be?" in The Lorax |
| 42% | BINGCROSBY | 10 | Crooner who sings "I've Got Plenty to Be Thankful For" in the Thanksgiving scene of 17-Across (2 wds.) |
| 42% | CHARLEMAGNE | 11 | King who was the son of Pepin the Short |
| 42% | MAY | 3 | "For Emily, Whenever I ___ Find Her," 1966 song by Simon & Garfunkel featuring Emily, who is just the kind of girl they sing songs about |
| 42% | ATTIC | 5 | I am a hidden room of mysteries nestled under the roof. Who am I? |
| 42% | ZEUS | 4 | The Greek god who was king of the gods of Mount Olympus |
| 42% | ALEXANDER | 9 | The great conqueror who was king of Macedonia |
| 42% | BOLEYN | 6 | Anne who was the mother of Elizabeth I |
| 41% | LEA | 3 | Actress Salonga who was the singing voice of Mulan |
| 41% | FIRE | 4 | I'm one of the classical elements who is associated with heat and dryness |
| 41% | HENRYI | 6 | English king who was a son of William the Conqueror |
| 41% | MINOS | 5 | Cretan king who was the son of Zeus and Europa |