| 100% | MYST | 4 | Best-selling 1993 video game set on an island |
| 78% | MYST | 4 | 1993 puzzle video game set on an island |
| 70% | MYST | 4 | 1993 computer game set on an island |
| 59% | MYST | 4 | Popular game set on an island |
| 59% | MYST | 4 | Computer game set on an island |
| 59% | CATAN | 5 | Board game set on an island |
| 59% | MYST | 4 | Classic game set on an island |
| 59% | MYST | 4 | Classic computer game set on an island |
| 59% | MYST | 4 | 1990s computer game set on an island |
| 59% | MYST | 4 | Groundbreaking computer game set on an island |
| 59% | MYST | 4 | Influential computer game set on an island |
| 56% | MYST | 4 | Classic computer game set on an abandoned island |
| 46% | TEMPEST | 7 | Play set on an island, with "The" |
| 46% | TYPEE | 5 | 1846 novel set on an island of cannibals |
| 45% | SIMISLE | 7 | 1995 sandbox video game set on a tropical archipelago |
| 45% | MYST | 4 | Classic computer game set on a seemingly deserted island |
| 44% | THETEMPEST | 10 | *Shakespeare play set on an enchanted island |
| 43% | MYST | 4 | Classic computer game set on a deserted island |
| 42% | UTOPIA | 6 | 1516 socio-political satirical novel by Thomas More that is set on an island |
| 42% | STORYMODE | 9 | Video game setting that allows a player to focus on the narrative |
| 42% | MYST | 4 | Pioneering nineties computer game set on a seemingly deserted island |
| 42% | NONE | 4 | "And Then There Were ___," 1939 novel by Agatha Christie that is set on an island |
| 41% | START | 5 | Button on an old video game controller |
| 41% | MAN | 3 | "The Old ___ and the Sea," 1952 novella by Ernest Hemingway that is set on an island |
| 41% | MYST | 4 | Video game named after an in-universe island |
| 41% | MYST | 4 | Pioneering computer game set in an island world |
| 40% | LUIGI | 5 | Video game character with an "L" on his hat |
| 40% | ENDWAR | 6 | Tom Clancy video game set during a global conflict sparked by an energy crisis |
| 39% | MINECRAFT | 9 | Sandbox video game released on November 18, 2011, that has become the best-selling video game of all time |
| 38% | EDEN | 4 | Survival thriller, set on an idyllic island in the Galápagos, that had its première at TIFF (September, 2024) |