| 100% | OTOOLE | 6 | Best Actor Oscar nominee for "The Lion in Winter" |
| 70% | AUSTINBUTLER | 12 | Best Actor Oscar nominee for his portrayal of the "King of Rock and Roll" in the 2022 film "Elvis" (2 wds.) |
| 68% | HURT | 4 | John —, Best Actor Oscar nominee for The Elephant Man |
| 68% | REA | 3 | Stephen —, Best Actor Oscar nominee for The Crying Game |
| 65% | LESLIEODOMJR | 12 | Nominee for the Best Supporting Actor and Best Original Song Oscars for his work in "One Night in Miami ...": 3 wds., abbr. |
| 65% | DUSTINHOFFMAN | 13 | Best Actor Oscar nominee for playing Benjamin Braddock in 28-Across (2 wds.) |
| 65% | RODSTEIGER | 10 | Best Actor in a Leading Role Oscar nominee for The Pawnbroker |
| 64% | COLINFARRELL | 12 | Best Actor Oscar nominee for his portrayal of a man who is suddenly cut out of the life of his best friend in the 2022 film "The Banshees of Inisherin" (2 wds.) |
| 64% | LEEJCOBB | 8 | Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar nominee for The Brothers Karamazov |
| 64% | HUMECRONYN | 10 | Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar nominee for The Seventh Cross |
| 64% | RANDYQUAID | 10 | Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar nominee for The Last Detail |
| 63% | DEVPATEL | 8 | Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar nominee for Lion |
| 62% | BRADLEYCOOPER | 13 | 2024 Best Actor Oscar nominee for portraying composer/conductor Leonard Bernstein in "Maestro" (2 wds.) |
| 62% | COLMANDOMINGO | 13 | 2024 Best Actor Oscar nominee for portraying civil rights leader Bayard Rustin in "Rustin" (2 wds.) |
| 62% | MAXVONSYDOW | 11 | Best Actor in a Leading Role Oscar nominee for Pelle the Conqueror |
| 61% | TOPOL | 5 | Best Actor in a Leading Role Oscar nominee for Fiddler on the Roof |
| 60% | HALEYJOEL | 9 | & 21A Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar nominee for The Sixth Sense |
| 59% | MICKEYROONEY | 12 | Best Actor in a Leading Role Oscar nominee for Babes in Arms and The Human Comedy |
| 59% | BRADDOURIF | 10 | Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar nominee for One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest |
| 59% | CLIFT | 5 | Montgomery —, Best Actor in a Leading Role Oscar nominee for The Search |
| 59% | GLEASON | 7 | Jackie —, Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar nominee for The Hustler |
| 59% | BALDWIN | 7 | Alec —, Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar nominee for The Cooler |
| 59% | WAHLBERG | 8 | Mark —, Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar nominee for The Departed |
| 59% | CAAN | 4 | James —, Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar nominee for The Godfather |