| 100% | AMECHE | 6 | Best Supporting Actor for "Cocoon" |
| 90% | AMECHE | 6 | Best Supporting Actor winner for "Cocoon" |
| 83% | MATTHAU | 7 | Best Supporting Actor for "The Fortune Cookie," 1966 |
| 82% | ALI | 3 | Mahershala ___, Best Supporting Actor for 17-Across |
| 80% | ALI | 3 | Best Supporting Actor winner for "Moonlight" |
| 80% | ALANARKIN | 9 | Best Supporting Actor nominee for "Argo" |
| 80% | ALI | 3 | Best Supporting Actor winner for “Moonlight” |
| 80% | LANDAU | 6 | Martin who won Best Supporting Actor for "Ed Wood" |
| 79% | LANDAU | 6 | Best Supporting Actor winner for "Ed Wood" |
| 79% | ALANALDA | 8 | Best Supporting Actor nominee for The Aviator |
| 78% | ALI | 3 | Best Supporting Actor winner for 2016 and 2018 |
| 78% | OMARSHARIF | 10 | Best Supporting Actor nominee for "Lawrence of Arabia" |
| 78% | LETO | 4 | Best Supporting Actor winner for "Dallas Buyers Club" |
| 77% | JAREDLETO | 9 | Best Supporting Actor winner for "Dallas Buyer's Club" |
| 77% | DELTORO | 7 | Benicio ___, Best Supporting Actor winner for "Traffic" |
| 77% | BARDEM | 6 | Best Supporting Actor winner for "No Country for Old Men" |
| 76% | ALBERTFINNEY | 12 | Best Supporting Actor Oscar nominee for 32-Across (2 wds.) |
| 76% | JONAHHILL | 9 | Best Supporting Actor nominee for The Wolf of Wall Street |
| 75% | ALPACINO | 8 | Best Supporting Actor nominee for 2019's "The Irishman": 2 wds. |
| 75% | JOEPESCI | 8 | Best Supporting Actor nominee for 2019's "The Irishman": 2 wds. |
| 75% | STAMP | 5 | Terence —, Best Supporting Actor Oscar nominee for Billy Budd |
| 75% | WAHLBERG | 8 | Mark —, Best Supporting Actor Oscar nominee for The Departed |
| 74% | ANTHONYHOPKINS | 14 | Best Supporting Actor nominee for 2019's "The Two Popes": 2 wds. |
| 74% | PESCI | 5 | Joe who won a Best Supporting Actor Oscar for "GoodFellas" |
| 74% | MAHERSHALAALI | 13 | Best Supporting Actor Oscar winner for the 2018 film "Green Book": 2 wds. |
| 73% | GARCIA | 6 | Andy —, Best Supporting Actor Oscar nominee for The Godfather: Part III |
| 73% | ALI | 3 | Film Jon Voight got a Best Supporting Actor Oscar nomination for |
| 72% | AMECHE | 6 | Actor Don who won a Best Supporting Actor Oscar for "Cocoon" |
| 72% | ROBIN | 5 | Williams who won a Best Supporting Actor Oscar for "Good Will Hunting" |
| 72% | ARKIN | 5 | Alan who won the Best Supporting Actor Oscar for "Little Miss Sunshine" |