| 100% | OMENS | 5 | Black cats and broken mirrors, by tradition |
| 71% | OMENS | 5 | Black cats and broken mirrors, stereotypically |
| 53% | OMENS | 5 | Black cats or broken mirrors, to some |
| 53% | OMEN | 4 | Black cat or broken mirror, to some |
| 52% | OMEN | 4 | Black cat or broken mirror, to a superstitious person |
| 51% | BADOMEN | 7 | Broken mirror or black cat, say |
| 47% | OMEN | 4 | Warning like a black cat or broken mirror |
| 45% | OMEN | 4 | A black cat or a broken mirror may be a bad one |
| 43% | OMOUT | 5 | Black cats and comets |
| 43% | OMENS | 5 | Black cats and others |
| 43% | OMENS | 5 | Black cats and comets, stereotypically |
| 41% | OMENS | 5 | Black cats and dark clouds, e.g. |
| 41% | OMENS | 5 | Black cats and red sunrises, to some |
| 40% | OMENS | 5 | Broken mirrors and others |
| 40% | OMENS | 5 | Black cats and comets, to people who are superstitious |
| 36% | UNLUCKY | 7 | A black cat, thought by some to be __ |
| 36% | OMENS | 5 | Breaking of a mirror and others |
| 35% | BURGLARY | 8 | Theft by breaking and entering |
| 35% | SYLVESTER | 9 | Black and white cat in Looney Tunes cartoons |
| 34% | OCELOT | 6 | Yellow and black cat |
| 33% | RITUAL | 6 | Gestures, words and objects set by tradition |
| 33% | INK | 3 | Black ___, raster-based digital art software developed and published by Bleank |
| 33% | LEOPARD | 7 | Large cat with a yellowish coat and black spots |
| 31% | FLY | 3 | "...Take these broken wings and learn to ___" ("Blackbird" by The Beatles) |
| 31% | VALENTINE | 9 | Cat played by 31-Across/33-Across on Nickelodeon's "Victorious" and "Sam & Cat" |
| 31% | FOURTHWALL | 10 | Thing broken by Deadpool (after 13-Down, 22-Down and 51-Down) |
| 31% | YEARONE | 7 | 2009 Jack Black film directed and cowritten by Harold Ramis: 2 wds. |
| 30% | BUTCH | 5 | ___ Cat, black and white alley cat in the animated children's series, "Tom & Jerry" |
| 30% | ASUSUAL | 7 | By tradition |
| 30% | PEKANS | 6 | Black cats |