| 100% | MYSTIQUE | 8 | Blue X-Men character who can shapeshift |
| 66% | PYRO | 4 | X-Men character who can control fire |
| 63% | STORM | 5 | "X-Men" character who can generate lightning |
| 62% | STORM | 5 | "X-Men" character who can control the weather |
| 51% | ELSA | 4 | "Frozen" character who says "You can't marry a man you just met" |
| 50% | STORM | 5 | X-Men character who controls weather |
| 48% | BEAST | 5 | Blue-haired fearsome X-Men character |
| 48% | MYSTIQUE | 8 | Blue, shapeshifting X-Men enemy |
| 47% | MAGNETO | 7 | X-Men villain who can control metals |
| 47% | PYRO | 4 | X-Men villain who can control fire |
| 45% | ELSA | 4 | Disney character who can make it snow |
| 45% | YOSHI | 5 | Super Mario character who can swallow enemies |
| 45% | MYSTIQUE | 8 | The X-Men mutant who shapeshifts into other people |
| 45% | GAMBIT | 6 | X-Men comic character who carries playing cards |
| 45% | LENNIE | 6 | Of Mice and Men character who befriends George |
| 45% | ELSA | 4 | Animated character who can create snow and ice |
| 45% | ELSA | 4 | Disney character who can control ice and snow |
| 45% | NEO | 3 | 1999 sci-fi character who can dodge bullets |
| 44% | LUIGI | 5 | Character who can be played in every installment of 26-Down |
| 44% | IRONFIST | 8 | Marvel character who can summon and focus his chi |
| 44% | YODA | 4 | "Star Wars" character who could this clue have written? |
| 44% | SMURF | 5 | Character who's blue in the face? |
| 44% | BEAST | 5 | "X-Men" character with blue fur |
| 43% | DONDRAPER | 9 | Mad Men character who made the finale's Coke ad |
| 43% | BIANCA | 6 | Shakespeare character who can't marry until her sister does |
| 43% | EEYORE | 6 | Gray story character who's blue |
| 43% | GENIE | 5 | Disney character who's always blue? |
| 43% | PILOT | 5 | Man who can fly? |
| 42% | PETER | 5 | ___ Pan, mischievous literary character who can fly and never grows up |
| 42% | SHREK | 5 | Kid-lit title character who could "vent smoke from either ear" |