| 100% | NEWHART | 7 | Bob who plays Papa Elf, Buddy's adopted dad |
| 48% | NEWHART | 7 | Bob —, US comedian who played Papa Elf in 2003 film Elf |
| 45% | JAMESCAAN | 9 | Actor who plays Buddy's father in Elf |
| 40% | CAAN | 4 | Actor James who played Buddy's father in "Elf" |
| 35% | NOLTE | 5 | Nick who played Bana's dad in "Hulk" |
| 34% | ONEAL | 5 | Ron who played Whitley's dad on "A Different World" |
| 33% | ARTHURLOWE | 10 | Actor who played Capt Mainwaring in BBC TV sitcom Dad's Army |
| 33% | LOWE | 4 | Arthur —, actor who played Capt Mainwaring in BBC TV sitcom Dad's Army |
| 33% | BECK | 4 | James —, actor who played Pte Walker in BBC TV sitcom Dad's Army |
| 33% | SAM | 3 | Actor Rockwell who played Bob Fosse in last year's miniseries "Fosse/Verdon" |
| 33% | ALEXKARRAS | 10 | Former NFL defensive tackle who played Webster's dad on "Webster" (2 wds.) |
| 33% | JOHNLAURIE | 10 | Scottish actor who played Private Frazer in BBC TV sitcom Dad's Army |
| 33% | NIGHY | 5 | Bill —, actor who played Sergeant Wilson in 2016 film comedy Dad's Army |
| 32% | BUSEY | 5 | Gary who played Buddy Holly |
| 32% | VENTIMIGLIA | 11 | Actor Milo ___, who plays Randall's adoptive dad Jack Pearson on "This Is Us" |
| 32% | GEORGECLOONEY | 13 | "Gravity" actor who plays Lily's divorced dad in "Ticket to Paradise": 2 wds. |
| 32% | JOEMANTEGNA | 11 | Three-time Emmy nominee who played Joan's dad on "Joan of Arcadia": 2 wds. |
| 31% | EBSEN | 5 | Buddy who played Barnaby |
| 31% | JOHNGOODMAN | 11 | "The Conners" actor who plays Papa Smurf in "Smurfs": 2 wds. |
| 31% | ETHAN | 5 | Actor Hawke who plays Dad in "Boyhood" |
| 31% | TARANKILLAM | 11 | Former "Saturday Night Live" actor who plays Sophie Cooper's dad on 28-Across (2 wds.) |
| 31% | EBSEN | 5 | Buddy who played Jed Clampett |
| 31% | EBSEN | 5 | Buddy who played Barnaby Jones |
| 30% | ASTIN | 5 | Actor Sean who played Bob on "Stranger Things" |
| 30% | SCOTTWOLF | 9 | "Party of Five" star who plays Nancy's dad on the CW's "Nancy Drew": 2 wds. |
| 30% | MICHAELPENA | 11 | "Narcos" actor who plays Dora's dad in "Dora and the Lost City of Gold" (2 wds.) |