| 100% | SLEEP | 5 | Bon Jovi "I'll ___ When I'm Dead" |
| 58% | DAVE | 4 | “I’ll Mature When I’m Dead” humorist ___ Barry |
| 49% | SLIPPERY | 8 | Bon Jovi hit album: __ When Wet |
| 46% | LAY | 3 | Bon Jovi's "___ Your Hands on Me" |
| 46% | SHE | 3 | Bon Jovi single "___ Don't Know Me" |
| 46% | DONTRUSHME | 10 | “I’ll go when I’m ready!” |
| 45% | GONE | 4 | "You'll miss me when I'm ___!" |
| 45% | LIVINONAPRAYER | 14 | 1986 Bon Jovi hit with the lyric "Take my hand, we'll make it, I swear" |
| 40% | IEAT | 4 | "___ when I'm upset" (consume): 2 wds. |
| 40% | TMI | 3 | Brief "Eww! Don't tell me that when I'm eating!" |
| 39% | ATME | 4 | ''Look __ when I'm talking to you!'' |
| 38% | IEAT | 4 | "___ ice cream when I'm upset": 2 wds. |
| 38% | KENNYBALL | 9 | Jazz trumpeter covered When I'm Sixty-Four |
| 38% | ALAD | 4 | When I was ___ ("H.M.S. Pinafore" song) |
| 38% | SEE | 3 | "I'll believe it when I ___ it" |
| 38% | SEE | 3 | "I'll believe it when I ___ it!" |
| 38% | ATME | 4 | "Look ___ when I'm talking to you!": 2 wds. |
| 38% | ATME | 4 | "Look ___ when I'm talking to you!" (2 wds.) |
| 38% | THERE | 5 | "I'll Be ___ For You," 1988 song by Bon Jovi that topped the US Billboard Hot 100 |
| 38% | OHSURE | 6 | "I'll believe it when I see it" |
| 38% | FAMOUSLASTWORDS | 15 | "I'll believe it when I see it!" |
| 37% | WET | 3 | "Slippery When ___" (Bon Jovi album) |
| 37% | OYSTERKNIFE | 11 | "what I mean when I say I'm sharpening my ___" (Ewing poem) |
| 37% | IEAT | 4 | "___ when I'm upset" (confession from a stress eater): 2 wds. |
| 37% | NOT | 3 | "Who Are You When I'm ___ Looking" (Blake Shelton song) |
| 37% | BOTTLEEPISODE | 13 | "___? That's an instance of when I'm feeding you" |
| 37% | ETA | 3 | "This is when I'm supposed to get there" stat |
| 37% | LIE | 3 | "I'm not gonna ___ ..." ("Believe me when I say ...") |
| 37% | THAT | 4 | "I'll cross ___ bridge when I get to it" |
| 37% | ISEE | 4 | I'll believe it when ___ it (2 wds) |