| 100% | ANYTHINGGOES | 12 | Broadway musical about a wrestling free-for-all? |
| 56% | BYEBYEBIRDIE | 12 | Broadway musical about a blown putt? |
| 54% | GRANDHOTEL | 10 | Broadway musical about a $1,000-a-night vacation? |
| 54% | GUYSANDDOLLS | 12 | Broadway musical about a G.I. Joe collectors' convention? |
| 54% | INTOTHEWOODS | 12 | Broadway musical about a duffer and his new driver? |
| 50% | PRODUCERS | 9 | The __, Mel Brooks musical about a Broadway flop |
| 50% | PIPPIN | 6 | Musical about a prince looking for his passion |
| 49% | WAITRESS | 8 | 2016 Broadway musical about a diner employee, based on a 2007 Keri Russell movie |
| 49% | HAIRSPRAY | 9 | 2002 Broadway musical about a Baltimore teenager, based on a 1988 John Waters movie |
| 49% | OLIVER | 6 | Broadway musical about an orphan based on a novel by Charles Dickens |
| 48% | ACHORUSLINE | 11 | Broadway musical about three guys using the same pickup routine at a bar? |
| 48% | CAMELOT | 7 | Broadway musical about King Arthur based on a book by T.H. White |
| 48% | WICKED | 6 | Broadway musical about the witches of Oz based on a novel by Gregory Maguire |
| 47% | MEANGIRLS | 9 | 2018 Broadway musical about a high school clique, based on a 2004 Lindsay Lohan movie: 2 wds. |
| 47% | SPAMALOT | 8 | 2005 Broadway musical about Arthurian legend, based on a 1975 Monty Python movie |
| 47% | CABARET | 7 | Broadway musical about a Berlin nightclub based on a play by John Van Druten and a novel by Christopher Isherwood |
| 47% | PUTNAM | 6 | County in a Broadway musical about a spelling bee |
| 46% | FIORELLO | 8 | 1959 Broadway musical that won a Pulitzer Prize for drama |
| 46% | CHER | 4 | "The ___ Show" (Broadway musical about a pop legend) |
| 44% | OPENBAR | 7 | Free drinks for all at a wedding reception |
| 44% | GOINGMYWAY | 10 | 1944 movie musical about a young parish priest that won an Oscar for Best Picture: 3 wds. |
| 44% | MYFAIRLADY | 10 | 1964 movie musical about a Cockney flower girl that won an Oscar for Best Picture: 3 wds. |
| 43% | TONY | 4 | Award for a Broadway musical |
| 43% | IRENE | 5 | 1919 Broadway musical that set a record for most performances up to that time |
| 43% | DAMNYANKEES | 11 | 1955 Broadway musical that earned Bob Fosse a Tony for Best Choreography: 2 wds. |
| 43% | WAITRESS | 8 | Broadway musical written by 31-Across that was nominated for four Tony Awards and a Grammy Award |
| 43% | IRAGERSHWIN | 11 | Lyricist whose 1931 Broadway musical Of Thee I Sing won a Pulitzer Prize for Drama |
| 42% | MYFAIRLADY | 10 | Broadway musical about Judge Judy? |
| 42% | RENT | 4 | Broadway musical about starving artists |
| 42% | CAMELOT | 7 | Broadway musical about King Arthur |