| 100% | TAPE | 4 | Bubble gum ___, food trend that was all the rage in the '90s |
| 85% | ICE | 3 | Teenage Ninja Turtle ___ Cream Bar, food trend that was all the rage in the '90s |
| 84% | ICE | 3 | Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtle ___ Cream Bar, food trend that was all the rage in the '90s |
| 58% | HUBBA | 5 | ___ Bubba Soda, bubble gum-flavored soda that was discontinued in the '90s |
| 43% | ELBE | 4 | Something that will take you by all the banks in Wittenberg |
| 43% | POGS | 4 | Game of milk caps that was popular among kids in the 90s and is one of the best-selling Christmas gifts |
| 43% | HUNGRIEST | 9 | The one that is the most in need of food |
| 42% | ERAS | 4 | The ___ Tour, Taylor Swift world tour that was trending in 2023 |
| 42% | LOLLIPOPS | 9 | Sweets that may have bubble gum in the center |
| 42% | LUNCHCOUNTER | 12 | Teacher checking that all the students are in the cafeteria? |
| 41% | CRUST | 5 | Stuffed ___ pizza, '90s food trend that was solidified by Pizza Hut |
| 41% | DOWN | 4 | Upside-___ puff pastry squares, dessert food that was trending in 2023 |
| 41% | ROLL | 4 | Fruit ___-up ice cream, dessert food that was trending in 2023 |
| 41% | LASAGNA | 7 | Monica's most popular dish that was present in almost all the get togethers in "Friends" |
| 41% | GTO | 3 | Pontiac that was the Motor Trend Car of the Year in 1968 |
| 40% | FURY | 4 | Word meaning "extreme rage" that is derived from the Erinyes in Greek mythology |
| 40% | BOY | 3 | Friar's Fat ___, fast food restaurant that is featured in the "Shrek" franchise and named after Friar Tuck |
| 40% | GTO | 3 | Pontiac muscle car that was the Motor Trend Car of the Year in 1968 |
| 40% | ESPN | 4 | Cable channel that was chronicled in the book "Those Guys Have All the Fun" |
| 40% | FAD | 3 | Thing that's all the rage |
| 39% | OVERSELLSVERSAILLES | 19 | Claims that Louis XIV's palace is better than all the other buildings in France combined? |
| 39% | BELLYACHE | 9 | Hit song by 30-Across that begins "Sittin' all alone / Mouth full of gum / In the driveway" |
| 38% | GIANT | 5 | ___ Sequoia, tree native to California that is amongst the largest in the world |
| 38% | TORNADO | 7 | "Bad luck, I guess … It was my turn, that's all. I was in the path of the ___" (quote from 18-Down) |
| 38% | GIBRALTAR | 9 | Strait that is a natural exit in the Mediterranean |
| 38% | ANTS | 4 | Insects that are attracted to sugar in the kitchen |
| 38% | MAC | 3 | ___ and cheese, a casserole baked in oven that is considered to be a comfort food in the US |
| 38% | IZOD | 4 | Shirt brand that was associated with preppies in the 1980s |
| 38% | ALTERNATIVE | 11 | ___ rock, style of music that was popularized in the 90s and has sub-genres like emo and post-grunge |
| 38% | EGGS | 4 | Food items that are often sold in dozens |