| 100% | HARDSAUCE | 9 | Butter and sugar mixture usually containing brandy or rum |
| 47% | EGGNOG | 6 | Brandy or rum added to whipped dairy products and sugar, basically |
| 42% | DAIQUIRI | 8 | Iced drink containing rum, lime juice and syrup or sugar |
| 35% | MOJITO | 6 | Rum cocktail containing sugar, lime, soda and mint |
| 31% | CREAM | 5 | Mix, as butter and sugar |
| 31% | EGGNOG | 6 | Drink of eggs, milk, sugar, spice and brandy that can be served hot or cold |
| 30% | CARAMEL | 7 | Sticky sweet substance made with butter and sugar |
| 29% | TOFFEE | 6 | A crunchy candy treat made from butter and sugar |
| 27% | TOFFEE | 6 | A candy made from butter and caramelized sugar |
| 27% | MOJITOS | 7 | Rum, sugar, lime and mint cocktails |
| 27% | HOTSAUCE | 8 | Condiment usually containing chili or peppers |
| 27% | TOFFEE | 6 | Boiled sugar and butter |
| 27% | TODDY | 5 | Mixture of spirits, sugar and hot water |
| 27% | MERINGUE | 8 | Mixture of sugar and whipped egg whites |
| 27% | SLEET | 5 | Mixture of rain and snow or hail |
| 26% | PECAN | 5 | Butter ___ (shelfmate of rocky road and rum raisin) |
| 26% | FEMUR | 5 | Supporter of iron and rum mixture |
| 26% | SALINE | 6 | A substance or mixture containing salt |
| 26% | FAT | 3 | What butter or oil may contain |
| 26% | REMOTE | 6 | Very far and usually isolated or secluded |
| 25% | EGGNOG | 6 | Sugar, milk, brandy and an ovum at Christmas |
| 25% | TOFFEE | 6 | A confection made by boiling sugar and butter |
| 25% | TOFFEE | 6 | Firm candy made by boiling sugar and butter |
| 25% | PENUCHE | 7 | Fudge candy made with brown sugar and butter |
| 25% | ROUX | 4 | Butter-and-flour mixture |
| 25% | OTIJOM | 6 | White rum, sugar, lime juice, soda water and garnish |
| 25% | FLAPJACK | 8 | Baked bar made with oats, syrup, sugar and butter |
| 25% | CARAMEL | 7 | Shade of brown made with melted sugar and butter |
| 25% | MACAROON | 8 | Cookie made of egg, sugar and almonds or coconut |
| 25% | BAGEL | 5 | It might have sugar and spice or everything. Nice! |