| 100% | ANE | 3 | Candy c___: hook shaped candy associated with Christmas |
| 44% | FIR | 3 | Tree associated with Christmas |
| 44% | MISTLETOE | 9 | Shrub associated with Christmas |
| 44% | POINSETTIA | 10 | Plant associated with Christmas |
| 44% | HOLLY | 5 | Plant associated with Christmas |
| 43% | MISTLETOE | 9 | Plant associated with Christmas kisses |
| 43% | MAGI | 4 | Wise men associated with Christmas |
| 43% | PLUM | 4 | ___ pudding (dessert associated with Christmas) |
| 43% | PEARTREE | 8 | Plant associated with Christmas carol partridge |
| 43% | BALSAM | 6 | Aromatic fir closely associated with Christmas |
| 43% | KINGS | 5 | Three __, star-followers associated with Christmas |
| 43% | NISSE | 5 | Nordic folklore creature associated with Christmas |
| 42% | HEART | 5 | Shape associated with February |
| 42% | DIAMOND | 7 | Shape associated with baseball |
| 42% | JELLY | 5 | ___ beans, small bean-shaped sugar candies often associated with Easter celebrations |
| 42% | STOLLEN | 7 | German spiced fruit cake associated with Christmas |
| 42% | ARC | 3 | Shape associated with a storyline |
| 41% | CANE | 4 | Shape of a striped Christmas candy |
| 40% | WREATH | 6 | Christmas-treat shape sometimes made with cornflakes |
| 40% | RED | 3 | Color associated with candy canes |
| 40% | CUBE | 4 | Solid shape associated with ice |
| 40% | CANE | 4 | Christmas candy shape |
| 40% | CANES | 5 | Christmas candy shapes |
| 40% | LAPLAND | 7 | Northernmost region of Finland associated with "Father Christmas" |
| 40% | PENTAGON | 8 | Shape associated with US's Department of Defense |
| 39% | SCURVY | 6 | Disease associated with vitamin C deficiency |
| 39% | CONE | 4 | Solid shape associated with ice cream |
| 39% | GEOMETRY | 8 | Branch of mathematics associated with shapes |
| 39% | CANE | 4 | Candy ___ Game, popular Christmas game played with sweet sticks |
| 39% | CANE | 4 | Shape of peppermint Christmas candy |