| 100% | WONKA | 5 | Candy man played by Depp |
| 58% | TODD | 4 | Demon barber played by Depp |
| 55% | BRASCO | 6 | Donnie played by Depp |
| 55% | TONTO | 5 | Sidekick played by Depp |
| 54% | TODD | 4 | Sweeney played by Johnny Depp |
| 54% | SPARROW | 7 | Pirate played by Johnny Depp |
| 50% | ABAGNALE | 8 | Frank __, Jr; con man played by DiCaprio in 2002 |
| 50% | SUPERMAN | 8 | Play by George Bernard Shaw: Man and __ |
| 49% | SPARROW | 7 | Captain Jack played by Johnny Depp |
| 49% | TODD | 4 | Barber Sweeney, played by Johnny Depp |
| 49% | SPARROW | 7 | Pirate Jack played by Johnny Depp |
| 49% | TODD | 4 | Sweeney ___ (role played by Johnny Depp) |
| 49% | EDNA | 4 | Broadway dame played by a man |
| 49% | KILLERJOE | 9 | Title hit man played by Matthew McConaughey in a 2011 film |
| 48% | SCISSOR | 7 | Edward __hands, character played by Johnny Depp |
| 48% | WONKA | 5 | Role played by Wilder, Depp, and Chalamet |
| 48% | EDNA | 4 | "Hairspray" mom usually played by a man |
| 47% | BABBITT | 7 | Raymond, played by Dustin Hoffman in Rain Man |
| 47% | DON | 3 | Draper played by Jon Hamm on "Mad Men" |
| 47% | LUIS | 4 | Fast-talking con man played by Michael Peña in the "Ant-Man" films |
| 47% | HATTER | 6 | Mad __, played by Johnny Depp in a Burton film |
| 47% | TONTO | 5 | Character played by Johnny Depp in "The Lone Ranger" |
| 47% | SPARROW | 7 | The surname of a pirate played by Johnny Depp |
| 47% | EDNA | 4 | "Hairspray" role traditionally played by a man in drag |
| 46% | JAMESBRADDOCK | 13 | Boxer played by Russell Crowe in "Cinderella Man" (2 wds.) |
| 45% | JOHNDILLINGER | 13 | Bank robber played by Johnny Depp in "Public Enemies": 2 wds. |
| 45% | ALAN | 4 | Brother played by Jon Cryer on "Two and a Half Men" |
| 44% | JAMESBARRIE | 11 | "Peter Pan" author played by Johnny Depp in "Finding Neverland": 2 wds. |
| 44% | PREJEAN | 7 | Real-life death penalty opponent played by Sarandon in "Dead Man Walking" |
| 44% | HARRYLIME | 9 | Character played by Orson Welles in 1949 film thriller The Third Man |