| 100% | PICKOFF | 7 | Catch between bases |
| 93% | TAGOUT | 6 | Catch between bases, say |
| 55% | NINETY | 6 | Distance between bases, in feet |
| 55% | PICKOFFS | 8 | Putouts of runners between bases |
| 55% | HARD | 4 | Caught between a rock and a ___ place |
| 55% | PLACE | 5 | Caught between a rock and a hard ___ |
| 54% | OUT | 3 | Caught off base |
| 54% | TAGS | 4 | Catches off base |
| 54% | PICKOFF | 7 | Putout of a player between bases |
| 52% | ANNA | 4 | Classic literary figure caught between two Alexeis |
| 52% | ILSA | 4 | She's caught between Rick and Victor |
| 52% | THIRD | 5 | Base between second and home |
| 51% | HARDPLACE | 9 | You get caught between a rock and here |
| 48% | ANNA | 4 | She's caught between two Alexeis in a classic novel |
| 48% | NINETY | 6 | Number of feet between baseball bases |
| 45% | AWOL | 4 | One caught off base, perhaps |
| 45% | NINETY | 6 | Distance between M.L.B. bases, in feet |
| 45% | NINETY | 6 | Number of feet between home and first base |
| 44% | BITTEN | 6 | "caught between teeth" |
| 42% | DADO | 4 | Part of a pedestal between the base and the cornice |
| 42% | SANDWICH | 8 | Food with bread as the base and meat in between |
| 42% | STEM | 4 | Part of a wineglass between the base and the bowl |
| 40% | HARDPLACE | 9 | "Caught between a rock and a __" |
| 39% | HARKNESS | 8 | ___ teaching, style of education based on a round-table discussion between students |
| 38% | AWOLS | 5 | They may be caught off base |
| 38% | WARPAINT | 8 | *2017 Broadway musical based on the rivalry between Elizabeth Arden and Helena Rubinstein |
| 37% | RHETT | 5 | "I can't go all my life waiting to catch you between husbands" speaker |
| 35% | OATS | 4 | Breakfast cereal grains which make it impossible to catch one of them between your teeth |
| 34% | HARDPLACE | 9 | People are often caught "between a rock and a __" |
| 34% | AWOL | 4 | One who may be caught off base |