| 100% | HOLM | 4 | Celeste —, Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Gentleman's Agreement |
| 75% | GORDON | 6 | Ruth —, Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Rosemary's Baby |
| 74% | RUTHERFORD | 10 | Margaret —, Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for The V.I.P.s |
| 74% | LEEGRANT | 8 | Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Shampoo |
| 74% | HELEN | 5 | Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Airport |
| 74% | SANDY | 5 | & 6D Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf? |
| 73% | TATUMONEAL | 10 | Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Paper Moon |
| 73% | HUDSON | 6 | Jennifer —, Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Dreamgirls |
| 73% | ZETAJONES | 9 | Catherine —, Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Chicago |
| 73% | UMEKI | 5 | Miyoshi —, Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Sayonara |
| 73% | HAYES | 5 | Helen —, Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Airport |
| 73% | HELEN | 5 | & 2D Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Airport |
| 72% | HAWN | 4 | Goldie —, Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Cactus Flower |
| 72% | SORVINO | 7 | Mira —, Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Mighty Aphrodite |
| 72% | JOLIE | 5 | Angelina —, Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Girl, Interrupted |
| 72% | ONEAL | 5 | Tatum —, Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Paper Moon |
| 72% | SWINTON | 7 | Tilda —, Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Michael Clayton |
| 72% | SPENCER | 7 | Octavia —, Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for The Help |
| 72% | TATUM | 5 | & 19A Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Paper Moon |
| 72% | ALICE | 5 | & 17D Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for In Old Chicago |
| 72% | CONNELLY | 8 | Jennifer —, Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for A Beautiful Mind |
| 72% | ASTOR | 5 | Mary —, Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for The Great Lie |
| 72% | STEENBURGEN | 11 | Mary —, Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for Melvin and Howard |
| 72% | WEISZ | 5 | Rachel —, Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for The Constant Gardener |
| 72% | TOMEI | 5 | Marisa —, Best Actress in a Supporting Role Oscar winner for My Cousin Vinny |