| 100% | YOSHI | 5 | Character who sometimes serves as Mario’s steed |
| 55% | WALUIGI | 7 | Purple-clad character who serves as a foil to Mario's brother in the "Super Mario Bros." series |
| 44% | PERSEPHONE | 10 | Goddess who serves as a major character in 2019's "Hadestown" |
| 38% | ROE | 3 | Fish eggs sometimes served as caviar |
| 37% | BURNS | 5 | Character who sometimes tells Smithers to "release the hounds" |
| 37% | OLAF | 4 | "Frozen" character who sometimes loses his head |
| 36% | SORBET | 6 | Frozen dessert sometimes served as a palate cleanser |
| 36% | ROBIN | 5 | "Teen Titans Go!" TV and movie character who started as Batman's sidekick |
| 36% | RAHM | 4 | Emanuel who currently serves as the U.S. Ambassador to Japan |
| 36% | KOCH | 4 | Mayor who later served as judge on "The People's Court" |
| 36% | ARYASTARK | 9 | Fantasy character who sometimes calls herself the "Night Wolf" |
| 36% | PENCE | 5 | V.P. who also served as Indiana's governor |
| 36% | DAYAN | 5 | Moshe who served as Israel’s defense minister |
| 35% | PELE | 4 | Athlete who once served as his country's Extraordinary Minister for Sport |
| 35% | OLYMPIAIRVING | 13 | Author who served as U.S. minister to Spain |
| 35% | POPEYE | 6 | Character who uses "yam" as a verb |
| 35% | APU | 3 | "The Simpsons" character who serves Squishees |
| 35% | LUIGI | 5 | Plumber character who is Mario's twin brother and sidekick in the video game franchise |
| 34% | RICHELIEU | 9 | Cardinal who served as Louis XIII’s chief minister |
| 34% | NED | 3 | ___ Schneebly, School of Rock teacher whom Jack Black's character poses as |
| 34% | REGAN | 5 | Character who refers to her father as “the lunatic king” |
| 34% | PAM | 3 | "The Office" character who started as a receptionist |
| 34% | EDGAR | 5 | Character who succeeds Lear as king of Britain |
| 34% | EGYPT | 5 | Land serving as inspiration for "The Mummy" characters |
| 33% | DDE | 3 | Pres. who served as NATO’s first Supreme Allied Commander Europe |
| 33% | CHURCHILL | 9 | Winston, who served as the UK's PM during WWII |
| 33% | TONYSOPRANO | 11 | TV character who fronted as a waste management consultant |
| 33% | TAFT | 4 | President who later served as chief justice |
| 33% | TAFT | 4 | President who also served as chief justice |
| 32% | BRUCEWAYNE | 10 | Wealthy comic book character who moonlights as Batman: 2 wds. |