| 100% | PINOCCHIO | 9 | Character whose nose grew with lies |
| 73% | PINOCCHIO | 9 | Fictional character whose nose grows when he lies |
| 57% | PINOCCHIO | 9 | Puppet whose nose grows when he lies |
| 56% | PINOCCHIO | 9 | Wooden puppet whose nose grows when he lies |
| 56% | PINOCCHIO | 9 | Puppet whose nose grows when he tells a lie |
| 53% | PINOCCHIO | 9 | Character with a lie-detector nose |
| 43% | PINOCCHIO | 9 | Animated film about a puppet whose nose grows |
| 41% | PINOCCHIO | 9 | His nose grows every time he lies |
| 40% | TOMTHUMB | 8 | Folklore character whose stockings are tied with eyelashes |
| 39% | NED | 3 | “The Simpsons” character whose full first name ends with -ward |
| 39% | ADULTS | 6 | “Peanuts” characters whose voices are typically replaced with trombone sounds |
| 38% | SNOOPY | 6 | Cartoon character with a big nose |
| 38% | OLAF | 4 | "Frozen" character with a carrot nose |
| 38% | SNOOPY | 6 | Comics character with a big nose |
| 38% | SLUGGO | 6 | Comics character with a pug nose |
| 37% | FONZ | 4 | 1970's TV character whose real first name was Arthur, with "the" |
| 37% | BERT | 4 | "Sesame Street" character with a big orange nose |
| 36% | HELEN | 5 | With 25 Across, author whose best-known character is named Jones |
| 36% | HENRY | 5 | With 25 Across, author whose best-known character is named Jones |
| 36% | OLAF | 4 | Disney character with stick arms and a carrot nose |
| 36% | GRIMACE | 7 | Purple character whose birthday was celebrated with a special McDonald's shake in 2023 |
| 35% | TINTIN | 6 | Adventurous comic character with a peculiar hairstyle whose name repeats itself |
| 34% | MADDY | 5 | “Euphoria” character whose confrontation with Cassie won the 2022 MTV Movie & TV Award for Best Fight |
| 33% | PEER | 4 | With 32-Across, Henrik Ibsen play whose title character has a series of disastrous adventures |
| 33% | EDTV | 4 | 1999 film whose main character goes on "The Tonight Show With Jay Leno" |
| 32% | CHUCKIEFINSTER | 14 | Nickelodeon cartoon character with red hair whose best friend is Tommy Pickles (2 wds.) |
| 32% | ROO | 3 | A.A. Milne character whose name rhymes with "Pooh" |
| 31% | ANANIAS | 7 | Biblical character who, along with wife Sapphira, was struck dead for lying |
| 31% | ISH | 3 | "Grown-___" (sitcom whose main character is Zoey Johnson) |
| 31% | PRINCESSMERIDA | 14 | Disney cartoon character with red hair whose best friend is a horse named Angus (2 wds.) |