| 100% | PEANUTBUTTERCUP | 15 | Chocolate treat that's geometrically a frustum |
| 46% | MACARON | 7 | Sweet, French treat that's a meringue sandwich |
| 46% | MILKYWAY | 8 | Chocolate bar that's also a galaxy |
| 44% | DONUT | 5 | Sweet treat that’s often shaped like a 36-Across |
| 44% | CHUNK | 5 | Chocolate piece that's bigger than a chip |
| 44% | CACAO | 5 | Tree that’s a chocolate source |
| 44% | CARROT | 6 | Veggie that's a rabbit treat |
| 43% | TOE | 3 | Digit that's treated in a pedicure |
| 43% | CAROB | 5 | Bean that's used as a chocolate substitute |
| 42% | CRONUT | 6 | Treat that’s a hybrid between a crescent-shaped pastry and a ring-shaped pastry |
| 42% | COOKIE | 6 | Baked treat with chocolate chips, or oatmeal and raisins, that might be enjoyed at a picnic |
| 42% | FUDGSICLE | 9 | Chocolate treat on a stick |
| 41% | URANIUMOREO | 11 | Treat that gives a glowing complexion? |
| 41% | SWEET | 5 | Treat that contrasts a savory dish |
| 41% | SUGARPLUM | 9 | Christmas treat that's also the name of a fairy in "The Nutcracker" (2 wds.) |
| 41% | TWIX | 4 | Chocolate, cookie, and caramel treat that comes two to a package |
| 41% | CRONUT | 6 | Round, flaky pastry that’s a hybrid of two breakfast treats |
| 40% | DONUT | 5 | Treat that might be chocolate or glazed |
| 40% | MUGCAKE | 7 | Treat that might be cooked in a microwave |
| 40% | FUDGSICLE | 9 | Frozen chocolate treat on a stick |
| 39% | ASTROPOP | 8 | Colorful treat that resembles a rocket |
| 38% | SUNDAE | 6 | Treat that may have a cherry on top |
| 38% | CHARCOALBISCUIT | 15 | Treat that can help a dog with indigestion |
| 38% | FUNSIZECANDYBAR | 15 | Small treat that often comes in a bag |
| 37% | WASHEDRIND | 10 | Term describing a cheese that's been treated with brine |
| 37% | TRUFFLE | 7 | Chocolate ganache treat named like a fungus |
| 37% | OREO | 4 | Treat that's sometimes dunked |
| 37% | BAGEL | 5 | Treat that's often toasted |
| 37% | CHESSPIES | 9 | Treats that would be apt desserts for a certain board game tournament |
| 37% | BROWNIES | 8 | Chocolaty treats that sometimes come in a "two-bite" variety |