| 100% | MICE | 4 | Cinderella's horses, before the spell |
| 57% | PUMPKIN | 7 | Cinderella's coach, before the ball |
| 49% | ALA | 3 | It goes before the carte, not the horse |
| 47% | MICE | 4 | Cinderella's horses |
| 47% | CART | 4 | It shouldn't be put before the horse, they say |
| 46% | MICE | 4 | Cinderella's horses, really |
| 46% | WRETCHEDINGRATE | 15 | Like Cinderella before the Prince? |
| 46% | MICE | 4 | Cinderella's horses, after midnight |
| 46% | MICE | 4 | Cinderella's horses, after 12 |
| 43% | CART | 4 | Put the ___ before the horse |
| 42% | PRETAXPROFITS | 13 | Earnings before the government's cut |
| 42% | INVERT | 6 | Put the cart before the horse, say |
| 42% | ALA | 3 | Phrase before the chef's last name |
| 42% | DARKEST | 7 | "It's always ___ before the dawn" |
| 42% | ALA | 3 | It's put before the carte? |
| 42% | ALA | 3 | What's put before the carte? |
| 42% | PESETA | 6 | Spain's currency before the euro |
| 42% | PLANA | 5 | It's tried before the fallback |
| 41% | NERO | 4 | Ruler who died before the fiddle's invention |
| 41% | SENATE | 6 | Obama's workplace before the White House |
| 41% | NONET | 5 | The planets, before Pluto's downgrade |
| 40% | SILVER | 6 | The Lone Ranger's white horse |
| 40% | ALL | 3 | "___ the king's horses ... " |
| 40% | BARRENARROW | 11 | Before the pass: unproductive + pointer > After: dancer's rail + thin |
| 40% | GODMOTHER | 9 | Cinderella's Fairy __ helps her go to the ball |
| 40% | MICE | 4 | Cinderella’s tiny dressmakers, in the 1950 Disney film |
| 40% | GRANDOLD | 8 | Adjectives before the nursery rhyme's Duke of York |
| 40% | SERIES | 6 | Word before the year on U.S. paper currency |
| 40% | TWEETING | 8 | Posting to X, before the platform's name changed |
| 40% | ILENE | 5 | The voice of Disney's Cinderella, ____ Woods |