| 100% | IGOTORIO | 8 | Classic song that begins "When my baby / When my baby smiles at me" |
| 87% | IGOTORIO | 8 | Classic song that starts “When my baby / When my baby smiles at me” |
| 55% | RIO | 3 | Where I go "when my baby smiles at me," in song |
| 47% | RIO | 3 | "When my baby smiles at me I go to ___" (Pablo Cruise lyric) |
| 46% | DAILEY | 6 | Dan ___, 1948 Best Actor nominee for "When My Baby Smiles at Me" |
| 44% | ORAL | 4 | Björk and Rosalía song that begins "Your mouth floats above my bed at night" |
| 44% | HEART | 5 | Song beginning "Well, since my baby left me" |
| 44% | ICRIED | 6 | Patti Page song that begins "It was winter when you told me you were leaving" |
| 43% | LAVENDERHAZE | 12 | Taylor Swift hit song that begins, "Meet me at midnight" (2 wds.) |
| 43% | MISTY | 5 | Johnny Mathis classic that begins, "Look at me" |
| 41% | FIELDSOFGOLD | 12 | 39-Across song that begins "You'll remember me when the west wind moves" (3 wds.) |
| 39% | LETITBE | 7 | Beatles song that begins, "When I find myself in times of trouble" (3 wds.) |
| 39% | LETITBE | 7 | Beatles song that begins "When I find myself in times of trouble" (3 wds.) |
| 39% | MYWAY | 5 | Classic song that begins "And now the end is near" |
| 38% | SOS | 3 | ABBA song with a chorus that begins "So when you're near me, darling, can't you hear me ..." |
| 36% | BLUEBERRYHILL | 13 | Hit song by 41-Across that begins, "I found my thrill ... " (2 wds.) |
| 36% | TREES | 5 | Classic poem that begins "I think that I shall never see" |
| 36% | BLITZKRIEGBOP | 13 | Classic 1976 Ramones song that begins "Hey! Ho! Let's go!" |
| 36% | LETITSNOW | 9 | When tripled, song that begins, "Oh, the weather outside is frightful" |
| 36% | ALLSTAR | 7 | Smash Mouth song that begins, "Somebody once told me ..." |
| 36% | SHAMBALA | 8 | Three Dog Night song that begins, “Wash away my troubles” |
| 35% | HEYYA | 5 | 2000s megahit that begins "My baby don't mess around / Because she loves me so" |
| 35% | ASP | 3 | Beast that Cleopatra calls "my baby at my breast," in "Antony and Cleopatra" |
| 35% | DIDNTSCALEWELL | 14 | "When that fell through, I tried my hand at fishmongering, but we …" |
| 35% | MARIA | 5 | 1957 song that begins "The most beautiful sound I ever heard …" |
| 35% | MARIA | 5 | Broadway song that begins, "The most beautiful sound I ever heard" |
| 35% | THEARCHER | 9 | Taylor Swift song that begins "Combat, I'm ready for combat" |
| 35% | MYWAY | 5 | Classic Frank Sinatra song that begins, "And now, the end is near" (2 wds.) |
| 35% | ITSOVER | 7 | Roy Orbison song that begins, “Your baby doesn’t love you anymore” |
| 34% | GIRL | 4 | Beatles song that begins "Is there anybody going to listen to my story" |