| 100% | TOES | 4 | Cold ones, unless you find that 20-Across |
| 40% | GLOVE | 5 | Protective hand covering, for one, that you may find in a first aid kit |
| 39% | ESCAPOLOGIST | 12 | Term that 20 Across coined for himself |
| 37% | PERSONALITY | 11 | You might think that a new one will lead to 40-Across |
| 37% | SOCK | 4 | Matching ___, one of a pair of feet warmers that seems impossible to find when you're looking for it |
| 37% | ORNO | 4 | “. . . unless you aren’t interested in that?” |
| 36% | BELOWTHEBELT | 12 | Grossly unfair, or where you find the last words of 20-, 29-, 38- and 47-Across |
| 35% | APPLESWEATSHIRT | 15 | In the study, you find that the thief accidentally left behind an ___ |
| 35% | TEARDUCT | 8 | One that gives you an eyeful? |
| 34% | SNEEZE | 6 | Cold symptom that elicits a "bless you" |
| 34% | LUMBERJACK | 10 | You might find one at a sawmill |
| 34% | SNOW | 4 | Blanket that makes you colder? |
| 34% | ERIE | 4 | That Great Lake you always find in crosswords |
| 34% | NEEDLE | 6 | You might find one under a Christmas tree |
| 34% | EMAIL | 5 | One might begin "Hope this finds you well" |
| 34% | POINTTAKEN | 10 | “I’ll give you that one” |
| 33% | AIRMASS | 7 | One of two that meet at a cold front |
| 33% | HIDE | 4 | Go where no one can find you |
| 33% | SYNONYM | 7 | Word that shares a similar meaning to another one, as you would find in a thesaurus |
| 33% | ALLOVERTHEMAP | 13 | Wildly diverse, and where you'll find the ends of 20-, 28-, 39- and 47-Across |
| 33% | PEELE | 5 | Director whose entire filmography is found in 13- and 19-Across (if you move one letter) |
| 32% | FLATEARTHER | 11 | One who says that you're not on the ball? |
| 32% | MSS | 3 | Those found in the Qumran Caves are notable ones (abbr.) |
| 32% | ARE | 3 | "( ___ You) The One That I've Been Waiting For" |
| 32% | TISSUE | 6 | *Nose wiper that you may find inside 1a. |
| 32% | KEYS | 4 | *Lock liberators that you may find inside 1a. |
| 32% | STASH | 5 | Supply that no one's supposed to find |
| 32% | GOLFTAN | 7 | Shade that one might find on the links? |
| 32% | UNDO | 4 | Computer command that takes you back one step |
| 32% | MTV | 3 | Cable channel that airs "Are You the One?" |