| 100% | EYES | 4 | Colon in an emoticon, often |
| 79% | EYES | 4 | Colon in an emoticon |
| 74% | EYES | 4 | Colon, in an emoticon |
| 73% | NOSE | 4 | What the hyphen in an emoticon often represents |
| 70% | EYES | 4 | Colon in many an emoticon |
| 65% | EYES | 4 | Colon, in many an emoticon |
| 65% | EYES | 4 | Colons often represent them in emoticons |
| 64% | EYES | 4 | Colon or semicolon, in an emoticon |
| 60% | EYES | 4 | What a colon represents in an emoticon |
| 59% | ISTO | 4 | Colon in an analogy |
| 59% | SMILE | 5 | ), in an emoticon |
| 58% | EYES | 4 | What a colon usually represents in an emoticon |
| 57% | GRIN | 4 | D, in an emoticon |
| 56% | LESSTHAN | 8 | Symbol in an emoticon heart |
| 54% | NOSE | 4 | What the hyphen in an emoticon represents |
| 54% | ISTO | 4 | Colon, in an analogy |
| 53% | COLON | 5 | Punctuation mark that makes eyes in an emoticon |
| 53% | FROWN | 5 | What a left parenthesis suggests in an emoticon |
| 53% | COLON | 5 | Punctuation mark representing the eyes in an emoticon |
| 53% | EYE | 3 | What a dot in an emoticon may represent |
| 53% | ISTO | 4 | Words represented by a colon in an analogy |
| 51% | EYES | 4 | What an emoticon's colon represents |
| 51% | SLUR | 4 | Word in an ethnic joke, often |
| 50% | NAME | 4 | First field in an online form, often |
| 50% | KEY | 3 | Hidden object in an escape room, often |
| 50% | EYES | 4 | Colon or semicolon, in emoticons |
| 49% | COG | 3 | Settings icon in an app, often |
| 48% | PLUMS | 5 | Fruit in an often-parodied William Carlos Williams poem |
| 47% | PHOTOCREDIT | 11 | What a camera emoji in an Instagram caption often signifies |
| 47% | DILIGENCE | 9 | In performing an investigation, it is often due |