| 100% | OREOS | 5 | Common ice cream mix-in |
| 76% | OREO | 4 | Ice cream mix-in |
| 68% | OREO | 4 | Popular cookie to crumble as an ice cream mix-in |
| 63% | CHOC | 4 | Common ice cream flavor, for short |
| 63% | VANILLA | 7 | Common ice cream; slang for dull |
| 59% | CONE | 4 | Ice cream parlor common order |
| 59% | GELATO | 6 | Ice cream in a trattoria |
| 59% | OREO | 4 | Cookie that's a common ice cream topping |
| 58% | SPA | 3 | Ice cream shop, in New England |
| 58% | CHOCOTACOS | 10 | Ice cream novelties discontinued in 2022 |
| 58% | PARFAITS | 8 | Ice cream treats in tall glasses |
| 57% | BANANASPLIT | 11 | Ice cream dessert served in a boat |
| 57% | DREYERS | 7 | Ice cream brand in West Coast supermarkets |
| 55% | SWIRL | 5 | Ice cream feature represented four times in this puzzle |
| 55% | SUNDAE | 6 | Ice cream treat in a glass, with a topping |
| 55% | VANILLA | 7 | Type of ice cream in an affogato |
| 55% | VANILLA | 7 | Shade of white like that of the most common ice cream flavor |
| 54% | HAAGENDAZS | 10 | Ice cream brand whose first storefront was in Brooklyn Heights |
| 54% | ALASKA | 6 | Cake and meringue cover ice cream in Baked __ |
| 54% | DRUMSTICK | 9 | Novelty ice cream invented in 1928 |
| 54% | VANILLA | 7 | Common ice-cream flavor |
| 54% | ALOEVERA | 8 | Plant common in creams |
| 53% | KLONDIKE | 8 | Ice cream bar brand named for a region in the Yukon |
| 53% | MERINGUE | 8 | This covers the ice cream in a baked Alaska |
| 53% | TINROOF | 7 | __ pie, ice cream cake with cornflakes in the base |
| 53% | CHOCOLATESWIRLS | 15 | Ice cream features found, in a way, in this puzzle's circles |
| 52% | RIO | 3 | "Cherry ice cream smile" wearer, in a Duran Duran hit |
| 52% | VANILLA | 7 | Type of ice cream in a black and white milkshake |
| 51% | ROLL | 4 | Fruit ___-up ice cream, dessert food that was trending in 2023 |
| 51% | CONE | 4 | Ice cream ___, wafer to hold ice cream that was popularized in the early 1900s |