| 100% | OREO | 4 | Cookie whose 2017 "Mystery Flavor" was revealed to be Fruity Pebbles |
| 71% | OREO | 4 | Brand whose 2017 mystery flavor was Fruity Pebbles |
| 48% | OREO | 4 | Cookie whose 2019 "mystery flavor" was churro |
| 41% | OREO | 4 | Cookie whose Double Stuf variety is closer to 1.86-times Stu |
| 38% | OREO | 4 | Cookie whose name origin is still a mystery |
| 38% | OREO | 4 | Cookie whose flavor is used in a lip balm |
| 37% | SASSAFRAS | 9 | Tree whose bark is used to flavor root beer |
| 37% | PEAT | 4 | Fuel whose smoke is used to flavor some Scotch |
| 36% | OREOS | 5 | Cookies with a 2017 "mystery flavor" |
| 36% | MINT | 4 | ___ flowers, edible flower whose leaf is used to flavor a mojito |
| 35% | DETECTIVE | 9 | A person whose job is to solve mysteries |
| 33% | OUTED | 5 | Revealed to be gay |
| 32% | DESPACITO | 9 | 2017 chart-topping hit whose YouTube video was the first to reach 3 billion views |
| 32% | KIDNAP | 6 | 2017 film whose story line is "every mother's nightmare," according to star Halle Berry |
| 32% | VANILLA | 7 | You will need some pure ___ extract to add flavor to a perfect cookie sandwich |
| 31% | OREO | 4 | Cookie whose Filled Cupcake version was introduced this year |
| 31% | HOBGOBLIN | 9 | Spiderman nemesis revealed to be Roderick Kingsley |
| 31% | CHO | 3 | Comedian Margaret who was revealed to be Poodle on "The Masked Singer" |
| 31% | APE | 3 | Resident of a planet that (spoiler alert) is revealed to be Earth |
| 30% | OREO | 4 | Cookie that Newman-O's are similar to |
| 30% | OREOS | 5 | Cookies with an occasional Mystery Flavor |
| 30% | TELLTALE | 8 | Revealing what is meant to be secret |
| 30% | OREO | 4 | Cookie whose current slogan is "Stay Playful" |
| 30% | OREO | 4 | Cookie whose name is hidden in "choreography" |
| 30% | PEPPERMEANT | 11 | Flavoring destined to be salt's companion? |
| 30% | TBA | 3 | Yet to be revealed: Abbr. |
| 29% | OREO | 4 | Sandwich cookie with a Peeps-flavored version that was released in 2017 |
| 29% | OREGON | 6 | State revealed to be home of The Simpsons in 2012 |
| 29% | SAFESEATS | 9 | Congressional positions whose general election races are easy to predict |
| 29% | OREO | 4 | Cookie whose crumbs are used in some piecrusts |