| 100% | MOTH | 4 | Creature that loves the spotlight? |
| 53% | BAT | 3 | Nocturnal creature that loves hanging upside down |
| 51% | DINOSAUR | 8 | Creature that roamed the planet before humans |
| 49% | PEARLFISH | 9 | Creatures that may live inside oysters - hence the name |
| 49% | RATS | 4 | Creatures that the Pied Piper was hired to remove |
| 48% | MUDPOODLE | 9 | Dog that loves to play in the rain? |
| 48% | MOONJELLY | 9 | Translucent sea creature that drifts with the current |
| 48% | CRAB | 4 | Sea creature that's featured in the zodiac |
| 48% | DEMENTOR | 8 | Foul creature that guarded Azkaban in the Potterverse |
| 48% | EARTHWORM | 9 | Wriggly garden creature that lives in the soil |
| 48% | MAGGOTS | 7 | Worm-like creatures that feed on the dead |
| 48% | SWORDFISH | 9 | Sea creature that resembles the maaarrrlin! |
| 48% | EARLYBIRD | 9 | Feathered creature that gets the worm |
| 48% | FROGS | 5 | Creatures that can freeze and thaw to survive the winter cold |
| 47% | GIANTSQUID | 10 | Creature that attacked the Nautilus in "Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea" |
| 46% | GOLLUM | 6 | Creature from The Hobbit who loves his "precious" |
| 46% | ANIMISM | 7 | The belief that objects and creatures have spirits |
| 46% | SERPENTS | 8 | Hissing creatures that formed the hair of Medusa |
| 46% | EMU | 3 | Creature that can fill the blank in L___R to make another creature |
| 46% | EEL | 3 | Creature that may travel to the Sargasso Sea to spawn and lay eggs |
| 46% | LOON | 4 | "Imaginary" creature that could appear in one of the starred answers |
| 46% | WREN | 4 | "Imaginary" creature that could appear in one of the starred answers |
| 46% | OWL | 3 | "Imaginary" creature that could appear in one of the starred answers |
| 46% | JAY | 3 | "Imaginary" creature that could appear in one of the starred answers |
| 46% | HAWK | 4 | "Imaginary" creature that could appear in one of the starred answers |
| 46% | CROW | 4 | "Imaginary" creature that could appear in one of the starred answers |
| 45% | DINOSAUR | 8 | Giant prehistoric creature that roamed the Earth |
| 45% | SNAKES | 6 | The only creatures that terrify Indiana Jones |
| 45% | BARNACLE | 8 | Hard-shelled creature that attaches itself to the bottom of a boat |
| 45% | YETI | 4 | Mythical creature that lives in the Chocolate Mountains, in Candy Crush Saga |