| 100% | SEATURTLES | 10 | Creatures that divers sometimes swim with |
| 43% | PORPOISE | 8 | Creature that echolocates with a melon |
| 42% | FISHPOND | 8 | Tiny reservoir for creatures that swim |
| 41% | GREMLIN | 7 | Fantastic creature that multiplies with water |
| 41% | EEL | 3 | Wriggly creature that rhymes with "squeal" |
| 41% | PET | 3 | Furry creature that lives with you |
| 41% | EELS | 4 | Long sea creatures that can swim backward |
| 41% | CYBORGS | 7 | Living creatures that are enhanced with robotics |
| 40% | MOONJELLY | 9 | Translucent sea creature that drifts with the current |
| 39% | BASILISK | 8 | Large serpent creature that can kill with a glance |
| 38% | ZEBRAS | 6 | Creatures that are actually black with white stripes |
| 38% | MANTICORE | 9 | Legendary creature that looks like a sphinx with a spiky tail |
| 37% | TEA | 3 | Drink that's sometimes served with crumpets |
| 37% | LOVE | 4 | Emotion that's sometimes confused with lust |
| 37% | OLIVES | 6 | Fruits that are sometimes stuffed with pimentos |
| 37% | HAM | 3 | Meat that's sometimes served with eggs |
| 37% | LAY | 3 | Word that's sometimes confused with "lie" |
| 37% | MAZE | 4 | Puzzle that's sometimes created with hedges |
| 37% | OLIVE | 5 | Fruit that's sometimes stuffed with a pimiento |
| 37% | SEAHORSE | 8 | Fish with a curly tail that swims upright |
| 37% | EEL | 3 | One that swims with a current? |
| 36% | PTA | 3 | Group that sometimes supports schools with bake sales: Abbr. |
| 36% | GRAM | 4 | Weight that is sometimes prefixed with "kilo" or "centi" |
| 35% | TOE | 3 | Boot part that's sometimes reinforced with steel |
| 35% | SMILING | 7 | With 3-Down, Adult Swim show about a business that makes people happy |
| 34% | ROTIFER | 7 | Microscopic animal that swims with whirling cilia |
| 32% | TROLL | 5 | Tall creature with great strength that the "Harry Potter" trio encountered in a bathroom |
| 32% | CRAB | 4 | Creature that sidles |
| 32% | COCOA | 5 | Hot ___ (drink that's sometimes topped with mini marshmallows) |
| 32% | OCTOPI | 6 | Erroneous but common plural for creatures with suction cups that can taste what they touch |