| 100% | FUMANCHU | 8 | Criminal genius with a distinctive long mustache |
| 51% | DALI | 4 | Surrealist with a distinctive mustache |
| 50% | DALI | 4 | Surrealist painter with a distinctive mustache |
| 48% | JOHNWATERS | 10 | "Hairspray" director/screenwriter with a distinctive mustache: 2 wds. |
| 47% | GERALDORIVERA | 13 | Fox News correspondent-at-large with a distinctive mustache: 2 wds. |
| 43% | SAMELLIOTT | 10 | "A Star Is Born" actor with a distinctive mustache: 2 wds. |
| 39% | GULL | 4 | Shorebird with a distinctive shriek |
| 39% | LIGHTSABER | 10 | Weapon with a distinctive hum |
| 39% | AUTEUR | 6 | Filmmaker with a distinctive style |
| 39% | CRAB | 4 | Animal with a distinctive walk |
| 39% | AUTEUR | 6 | Director with a distinctive style |
| 39% | KIDNEY | 6 | Organ with a distinctive shape |
| 39% | SWISSROLL | 9 | Cake with a distinctive swirl |
| 39% | ELMO | 4 | Muppet with a distinctive laugh |
| 39% | DEXTER | 6 | Boy genius with a secret laboratory |
| 39% | LAUGHINGGULL | 12 | Seashore bird with a distinctive cry |
| 39% | SERGE | 5 | Material with a distinctive diagonal weave |
| 39% | POM | 3 | Juice brand with a distinctive bottle |
| 39% | PEEPER | 6 | Tree frog with a distinctive call |
| 39% | HOOTOWL | 7 | Nocturnal hunter with a distinctive call |
| 39% | MAO | 3 | World leader with a distinctive jacket |
| 39% | NEWCAR | 6 | Pricey purchase with a distinctive smell |
| 39% | BLUEBILL | 8 | Duck with a distinctive colored bill |
| 39% | BABOON | 6 | Large monkey, with a distinctive rear |
| 39% | STARNOSEDMOLE | 13 | Small mammal with a distinctive snout |
| 39% | TEMPEH | 6 | Soybean protein with a distinctive taste |
| 39% | JAWS | 4 | Shark movie with a distinctive soundtrack |
| 39% | REGGAE | 6 | Jamaican music with a distinctive beat |
| 39% | NEWCAR | 6 | Expensive purchase with a distinctive smell |
| 39% | MAO | 3 | World leader with a distinctive suit |