| 100% | ERICA | 5 | D&D and ice cream enthusiast in "Stranger Things" |
| 45% | OREO | 4 | Traditional ingredient in cookies and cream ice cream |
| 45% | OREOS | 5 | Cookies commonly in cookies and cream ice cream |
| 45% | ALASKA | 6 | Cake and meringue cover ice cream in Baked __ |
| 45% | OREO | 4 | The cookie in "cookies and cream" ice cream, typically |
| 44% | EGOS | 4 | Big things in D.C. and Hollywood |
| 44% | VANILLA | 7 | Type of ice cream in a black and white milkshake |
| 42% | POP | 3 | *"___! Goes the Weasel," traditional song that is used in Jack-in-the-boxes and ice cream trucks |
| 41% | BAKED | 5 | With 22-Down, dessert consisting of ice cream and cake covered in toasted meringue |
| 41% | DAIRY | 5 | Aisle in the grocery store where one can find ice cream, milk, yogurt, and more |
| 41% | SODAS | 5 | Cream and ice cream |
| 41% | BOTHSIDESNOW | 12 | 12-Down hit song that begins with the lyrics "Rows and flows of angel hair / And ice cream castles in the air" (3 wds.) |
| 40% | BAKEDALASKA | 11 | Ice cream and sponge topped with meringue and placed in a very hot oven for a few minutes |
| 40% | OREO | 4 | Cookie in cookies-and-cream ice cream |
| 40% | ALASKA | 6 | Baked ___, dessert containing ice cream and cake named after a state in the western United States |
| 40% | DULCE | 5 | ___ de leche, popular ice cream flavor that originated in Latin America and is similar to caramel |
| 40% | OREO | 4 | Cookie found in cookies-and-cream ice cream |
| 40% | PISTACHIO | 9 | Popular ice cream flavor which is green in color and contains nuts popular in the Middle East |
| 39% | PARFAITS | 8 | Ice cream treats in tall glasses |
| 39% | OREO | 4 | Cookie typically used in cookies-and-cream ice cream |
| 39% | OREO | 4 | Type of cookie in cookies-and-cream ice cream |
| 39% | OREO | 4 | Cookie often found in cookies-and-cream ice cream |
| 39% | OREO | 4 | Cookie often used in cookies-and-cream ice cream |
| 39% | OREOS | 5 | The cookies in cookies-and-cream ice cream, often |
| 39% | DREYERS | 7 | Ice cream brand in West Coast supermarkets |
| 39% | DESSERTS | 8 | Cakes, pies, and ice cream |
| 39% | DEMODOG | 7 | Adolescent Demogorgon in Stranger Things |
| 39% | SHANNON | 7 | __ Purser, Barb in Stranger Things |
| 39% | AFFOGATO | 8 | Coffee and ice cream drink |
| 38% | CALORIC | 7 | Like French fries and ice cream |