| 100% | REEVE | 5 | D A —, cricketer; 1992 England Test debutant against New Zealand in Christchurch |
| 63% | REEVE | 5 | D A —, cricketer whose 1992 England Test debut was against New Zealand at Christchurch |
| 57% | PIGOTT | 6 | A C S —, England cricketer; 1984 one-Test wonder against New Zealand in Christchurch |
| 56% | ASTLE | 5 | N J —, New Zealand Test cricketer who made 222 against England in Christchurch in 2002 |
| 56% | ASTLE | 5 | N J —, New Zealand Test cricketer who hit 222 against England at Christchurch in 2002 |
| 55% | MADDY | 5 | D L —, 1993-2006 Leicestershire cricketer; 1999 England Test debutant against New Zealand at the Oval |
| 54% | CROFT | 5 | R D B —, England Test cricketer who took 5-95 against New Zealand at Christchurch in 1997 |
| 51% | VETTORI | 7 | D L —, New Zealand Test cricketer who took 5-69 against England at Lord's in 2008 |
| 50% | KNOTT | 5 | A P E —, England Test cricketer who hit 101 against New Zealand at Auckland in 1971 |
| 50% | BRACKEN | 7 | Kyran —, rugby union scrum half; 1993 England Test debutant against New Zealand |
| 50% | ORAM | 4 | J D P —, New Zealand Test cricketer who hit 101 against England at Lord's in 2008 |
| 50% | ORAM | 4 | J D P —, New Zealand Test cricketer who made 101 against England at Lord's in 2008 |
| 49% | KNOTT | 5 | A P E —, England Test cricketer who hit 101 against New Zealand in Auckland in 1971 |
| 49% | KNOTT | 5 | A P E —, England Test cricketer who made 101 against New Zealand in Auckland in 1971 |
| 48% | COMPTON | 7 | N R D —, England Test cricketer who made 117 against New Zealand in Dunedin in 2013 |
| 48% | GOWER | 5 | D I —, England Test cricketer who hit 111 against New Zealand at The Oval in 1978 |
| 48% | RICHARDSON | 10 | M H —, New Zealand Test cricketer who hit 101 against England at Lord's in 2004 |
| 48% | DILLEY | 6 | G R —, England Test cricketer who took 6-38 against New Zealand at Christchurch in 1988 |
| 48% | MOXON | 5 | M D —, England Test cricketer who hit 99 against New Zealand at Auckland in 1988 |
| 48% | ATHERTON | 8 | M A —, England Test cricketer who hit 151 against New Zealand at Nottingham in 1990 |
| 48% | ATHERTON | 8 | M A -, England Test cricketer who hit 151 against New Zealand at Nottingham in 1990 |
| 47% | LOCK | 4 | G A R —, England Test cricketer who took 7-35 against New Zealand in Manchester in 1958 |
| 46% | CARBERRY | 8 | M A —, former Hants cricketer; 2010 England Test debutant against Bangladesh in Chittagong |
| 45% | NASH | 4 | D J —, New Zealand Test cricketer who took 6-27 against India in Mohali in 1999 |
| 44% | CROWE | 5 | M D —, New Zealand Test cricketer who hit 299 against Sri Lanka at Wellington in 1991 |
| 43% | BOON | 4 | D C —, Australia Test cricketer who hit 200 against New Zealand in Perth in 1989 |
| 43% | BORDER | 6 | A R —, Australia Test cricketer who hit 205 against New Zealand in Adelaide in 1987 |
| 42% | GREIGLAIDLAW | 12 | Scrum-half; 2010 Scotland Test debutant against New Zealand |
| 41% | UBOGU | 5 | Victor —, rugby union prop; 1992 England Test debutant against Canada |