| 100% | CHEESE | 6 | Dairy product widely used as a pizza topping |
| 76% | CHEESE | 6 | Dairy product used as a pizza topping |
| 59% | ANCHOVY | 7 | Small, pickled fish used as a pizza topping |
| 48% | BANANAPEPPER | 12 | Yellow veggie often pickled as a pizza topping |
| 48% | SOUR | 4 | ___ cream, fermented dairy product that's commonly used as a topping on 22a |
| 47% | MUSHROOM | 8 | A fungus commonly used as pizza topping |
| 46% | NAAN | 4 | Bread sometimes used as a pizza crust |
| 44% | TOMATO | 6 | Shade of red you might use as a pizza sauce |
| 44% | LOX | 3 | Cured salmon used as a 7-Down topping |
| 44% | CHIASEEDS | 9 | "Superfood" commonly used as a smoothie bowl topping |
| 44% | LOX | 3 | Fish used as a topping on bagels |
| 44% | OREO | 4 | Cookie used as a 12-Down topping |
| 43% | LOX | 3 | Fish used as a bagel topping |
| 43% | OREO | 4 | Cookie used as a froyo topping |
| 42% | CRUMBS | 6 | Small bread pieces, can be used as a topping |
| 42% | CAPER | 5 | Pickled flower bud used as a bagel topping |
| 42% | ANCHOVIES | 9 | Salty fish used as pizza topping |
| 42% | ANCHOVIES | 9 | Fish sometimes used as pizza toppings |
| 41% | ANGEL | 5 | Heavenly being that may be used as a Christmas tree topper |
| 41% | STAR | 4 | Nighttime twinkler that may be used as a Christmas tree topper |
| 41% | LOX | 3 | Brined fish used as a bagel topping |
| 41% | LOX | 3 | Cured salmon used as a bagel topping |
| 41% | LOX | 3 | Smoked salmon used as a bagel topping |
| 41% | WOODEAR | 7 | Mushroom commonly used as a ramen topping |
| 41% | BUTTER | 6 | Dairy product used to coat pigs in a blanket, sometimes |
| 40% | MANURE | 6 | Waste product used as a fertilizer |
| 40% | PLAIN | 5 | Without toppings, as a pizza |
| 40% | SALSA | 5 | Spicy tomato-based condiment that is commonly used as a topping on 22a |
| 38% | PLAIN | 5 | Having no toppings, as a pizza |
| 38% | LETTUCE | 7 | Leafy salad ingredient with 'Romaine' and 'Butterhead' varieties that's commonly used as a topping on 22a |