| 100% | CIPRIANI | 8 | Danny —, former Wasps and Sale Sharks rugby union fly-half; 2008 England Test debutant against Wales |
| 89% | CIPRIANI | 8 | Danny —, Wasps and former Sale Sharks rugby union fly-half; 2008 England Test debutant against Wales |
| 72% | CIPRIANI | 8 | Danny —, former Sale Sharks and Wasps fly-half signed by Gloucester Rugby for 2018-19; 2008 England Test debutant against Wales |
| 51% | DWAYNEPEEL | 10 | Former Scarlets, Bristol Rugby and Sale Sharks scrum-half; 2001 Wales Test debutant against Japan |
| 49% | WATKINS | 7 | David —, rugby union fly-half, 1963 Wales Test debutant against England in the Five Nations |
| 46% | DANNY | 5 | & 14D Bath and former Wasps fly-half whose 2008 England Test debut was against Wales |
| 45% | CIPRIANI | 8 | Danny —, former Sale Sharks and Wasps fly-half with 16 England caps; formally retired in 2024 |
| 44% | HOOK | 4 | James —, rugby union fly-half; 2006 Wales Test debutant against Argentina |
| 44% | RIKIFLUTEY | 10 | Former London Irish and Wasps centre; 2008 England Test debutant against Pacific Islanders |
| 43% | MACGINTY | 8 | AJ —, United States and Sale Sharks rugby union fly-half |
| 42% | JAMIENOON | 9 | Former Newcastle Falcons and CA Brive rugby union centre; 2001 England Test debutant against Canada |
| 42% | ROKOCOKO | 8 | Joe —, former Blues and Racing 92 rugby union wing; 2003 New Zealand Test debutant against England |
| 42% | ANDY | 4 | & 24A Retired rugby union fly-half; 2005 England Test debutant against Italy |
| 42% | ANDREW | 6 | Rob —, rugby union fly-half; 1985 England Test debutant against Romania |
| 42% | FLOOD | 5 | Toby —, rugby union fly-half; 2006 England Test debutant against Argentina |
| 42% | TRINHDUC | 8 | Francois —, rugby union fly-half; 2008 France Test debutant against Scotland |
| 41% | DANPARKS | 8 | Australia-born rugby union fly-half; 2004 Scotland Test debutant against Wales |
| 41% | UGOMONYE | 8 | Retired Harlequins rugby union wing; 2008 England Test debutant against Pacific Islanders |
| 40% | VYVYAN | 6 | Hugh —, former Newcastle and Saracens rugby union lock; 2004 England Test debutant against Canada |
| 40% | NEARY | 5 | Tony —, rugby union flanker; 1971 England Test debutant against Wales |
| 40% | CATT | 4 | Mike —, rugby union utility back; 1994 England Test debutant against Wales |
| 39% | LYNAGH | 6 | Michael —, rugby union fly-half; 1984 Australia Test debutant against Fiji |
| 39% | CONTEPOMI | 9 | Felipe —, rugby union fly-half; 1998 Argentina Test debutant against Chile |
| 39% | MERCERON | 8 | Gerald —, rugby union fly-half; 1999 France Test debutant against Romania |
| 39% | ELLA | 4 | Mark —, rugby union fly-half; 1980 Australia Test debutant against New Zealand |
| 39% | MARK | 4 | & 19D Rugby union fly-half; 1980 Australia Test debutant against New Zealand |
| 39% | KRISBURTON | 10 | Australia-born rugby union fly-half; 2007 Italy Test debutant against Uruguay |