| 100% | STIEB | 5 | Dave ___, seven-time All-Star pitcher for the Blue Jays |
| 76% | STIEB | 5 | Seven-time All-Star Dave, who pitched for the Toronto Blue Jays |
| 57% | STIEB | 5 | Seven-time All-Star pitcher Dave |
| 54% | LEITER | 6 | Pitcher Al for the Blue Jays and Mets |
| 51% | CYYOUNG | 7 | Award named for the winningest pitcher of all time |
| 49% | SATCHELPAIGE | 12 | Star pitcher for the Kansas City Monarchs |
| 49% | TOR | 3 | Abbr. for the Blue Jays |
| 47% | SALE | 4 | Seven-time All-Star pitcher Chris |
| 42% | LOVE | 4 | "___ Story," 1970 film starring Ray Milland that's one of the highest-grossing films of all time adjusted for inflation |
| 42% | ACE | 3 | Bird mascot for the Toronto Blue Jays |
| 42% | MLB | 3 | Organization for the Toronto Blue Jays: Abbr. |
| 42% | VLADGUERREROJR | 14 | Toronto Blue Jays infielder/designated hitter who was the MVP of the 2021 MLB All-Star Game |
| 41% | DUNEDIN | 7 | Florida spring training site for the Toronto Blue Jays |
| 41% | CIRCLEOFFRIENDS | 15 | Shape's pick for the best movie of all time? |
| 41% | RAGINGBULL | 10 | Mad's pick for the best movie of all time? |
| 40% | JAMIEMOYER | 10 | Pitcher for the Mariners and seven other teams in the 1980s, 1990s, 2000s, and 2010s: 2 wds. |
| 40% | SCHOOLOFROCK | 12 | Rolling Stone's pick for the best movie of all time? |
| 40% | TERCALLSAUL | 11 | Prequel show nominated for the Outstanding Drama Series Emmy seven times |
| 40% | NOLANRYAN | 9 | Pitcher who holds the MLB all-time record with 5,714 strikeouts and seven no-hitters (2 wds.) |
| 40% | ROYHALLADAY | 11 | Blue Jays pitcher inducted into the MLB Hall of Fame in 2019: 2 wds. |
| 39% | MOBY | 4 | Electronic musician known for the song "We Are All Made of Stars" |
| 39% | ACES | 4 | Pitchers likely to be selected for the All-Star Game |
| 39% | CATOSTERMAN | 11 | One of the greatest pitchers of all time |
| 39% | MARC | 4 | ___ Shaiman, American composer who has been nominated seven times for the Academy Awards |
| 39% | SYLVESTERSTALLONE | 17 | The bartender poured beers for all the action movie stars, including ___ |
| 38% | ONCE | 4 | ___ and for all (for the last time) |
| 38% | STIEB | 5 | Toronto All-Star pitcher Dave |
| 38% | JUAN | 4 | All-Star pitcher ___ Marichal, nicknamed the Dominican Dandy |
| 38% | BROOKE | 6 | Zinzan ___, former New Zealand rugby player who played for the All Blacks and Auckland Blues |
| 38% | CARAFE | 6 | Pitcher for the reds? |