| 100% | SWINGVOTE | 9 | Difference-maker in a 5-4 Supreme Court decision |
| 81% | SWINGVOTE | 9 | Figure in a 5-4 Supreme Court decision |
| 60% | DRED | 4 | Plaintiff Scott in a landmark 1857 Supreme Court decision |
| 54% | DISSENT | 7 | Be the 4 in a 5-4 decision |
| 53% | ROE | 3 | Name in a landmark Supreme Court decision |
| 53% | DRED | 4 | Scott in a historic Supreme Court decision |
| 46% | ROE | 3 | Alias in a landmark Supreme Court case |
| 46% | DRED | 4 | Scott in a landmark Supreme Court case |
| 46% | VERDICT | 7 | Decision in a court case |
| 45% | ALGORE | 6 | Losing side in a 2000 Supreme Court ruling |
| 45% | GORE | 4 | Loser in a momentous 2000 Supreme Court case |
| 45% | ROE | 3 | Winner in a landmark 1973 Supreme Court case |
| 45% | ROE | 3 | Name in a landmark 1973 Supreme Court case |
| 45% | ROE | 3 | Wade's opponent in a landmark Supreme Court case |
| 45% | ROE | 3 | Wade's opponent in a 1973 Supreme Court case |
| 45% | ROE | 3 | Wade's opponent in a famous Supreme Court case |
| 44% | STEVENS | 7 | Former Supreme Court justice often seen in a bow tie |
| 44% | OBAMACARE | 9 | Subject of a landmark 2012 Supreme Court decision |
| 44% | DIRECTOR | 8 | Decision-maker in a business; film maker |
| 44% | RULE | 4 | Hand down a decision in court |
| 43% | GORE | 4 | Name in a 2000 Supreme Court case about voting in Florida |
| 43% | ROE | 3 | Alias in a landmark Supreme Court case for women's rights |
| 43% | REACHADECISION | 14 | Agree, like the Supreme Court in a 2000 case involving chads |
| 43% | ROE | 3 | Anonymous plaintiff in a landmark 1973 Supreme Court case |
| 43% | ACA | 3 | Subject of a landmark 2012 Supreme Court decision, for short |
| 42% | ASSISTS | 7 | There are two in a 5-4-3 double play |
| 42% | TOMATO | 6 | In 1893, the Supreme Court ruled it a vegetable |
| 42% | ROE | 3 | Start of a 1973 Supreme Court decision |
| 42% | OBAMACARE | 9 | Subject of a 2012 Supreme Court decision |
| 42% | ELENAKAGAN | 10 | Supreme Court justice since 2010 and winner of a National Merit Scholarship in 1977: 2 wds. |