| 100% | ALER | 4 | DiMag, e.g., for his entire career |
| 65% | TIGER | 5 | Al Kaline, for his entire career |
| 65% | ASTRO | 5 | Craig Biggio, for his entire career |
| 65% | STEELER | 7 | Terry Bradshaw, for his entire career |
| 65% | PIRATE | 6 | Roberto Clemente, for his entire career |
| 64% | ROYAL | 5 | 5-Down, for his entire career |
| 62% | SPUR | 4 | NBA great Tim Duncan, for his entire career |
| 62% | CELTIC | 6 | Bird, for his entire playing career |
| 61% | RAM | 3 | Merlin Olsen, for his entire pro career |
| 61% | PACER | 5 | Reggie Miller, for his entire NBA career |
| 61% | NAT | 3 | Ryan Zimmerman, for his entire MLB career |
| 61% | FLYER | 5 | Bobby Clarke, for his entire NHL career |
| 61% | ASTRO | 5 | Baseball player Jeff Bagwell was one for his entire career |
| 60% | DEREKJETER | 10 | Yankee who played the same infield position for his entire career |
| 59% | PACER | 5 | Reggie Miller, for his entire 18-year career |
| 59% | ORIOLE | 6 | Cal Ripken, for his entire major-league career |
| 59% | BROOKLYNDODGER | 14 | 52-Across, for his entire Major League career |
| 59% | NAT | 3 | Ryan Zimmerman, for his entire 17-year career |
| 58% | STEELER | 7 | 58-Across, for his entire N.F.L. career |
| 56% | NYGIANT | 7 | Lawrence Taylor, for his entire N.F.L. career, in brief |
| 44% | RAM | 3 | Merlin Olsen, for his whole NFL career |
| 44% | ORIOLE | 6 | Jim Palmer, for his whole MLB career |
| 42% | PIRATE | 6 | Willie Stargell, for his 21-year baseball career |
| 42% | JET | 3 | Namath, for most of his career |
| 41% | LAKERS | 6 | Kobe Bryant's team for his whole NBA career |
| 41% | TIGER | 5 | Ty Cobb, for most of his career |
| 41% | RED | 3 | 1-Across, for most of his career |
| 41% | MET | 3 | Tom Seaver, for most of his career |
| 41% | CELT | 4 | Bob Cousy, for most of his career |
| 41% | COLT | 4 | Johnny Unitas, for most of his career |