| 100% | DUNKS | 5 | Dips in milk, as an Oreo |
| 77% | DUNK | 4 | Immerse in milk, as an Oreo |
| 58% | SOGGY | 5 | Like an Oreo left in milk, say |
| 57% | STYX | 4 | Achilles was dipped in it as an infant |
| 56% | SAG | 3 | Dip in the middle, as the roof of an old shack |
| 49% | OREOS | 5 | Snacks dipped in milk |
| 49% | OREO | 4 | Cookie dipped in milk |
| 49% | OREO | 4 | It's dipped in milk |
| 49% | OREO | 4 | Cookie often dipped in milk |
| 49% | OREOS | 5 | Treats often dipped in milk |
| 48% | OREO | 4 | It may get dipped in milk |
| 48% | OREO | 4 | Cookie that's dipped in milk |
| 48% | OREO | 4 | Twistable treat often dipped in milk |
| 47% | OREO | 4 | Cookie that may be dipped in milk |
| 46% | OLDFASHIONEDIDEA | 16 | "This doughnut would be great dipped in milk!" |
| 46% | BTW | 3 | As an aside, in a text |
| 46% | ORCA | 4 | Marine mammal with the same colors as an Oreo |
| 45% | SAGS | 4 | Dips in the middle, like an old mattress |
| 44% | SAG | 3 | Dip in the middle, like an old mattress |
| 44% | SAG | 3 | Dip in the middle, like an old sofa |
| 44% | DUNK | 4 | Dip into milk, as a cookie |
| 44% | REPS | 4 | Handles, as an account, in brief |
| 44% | NARKED | 6 | Acted as an informant, in Ipswich |
| 44% | VOTEOUT | 7 | Reject, as an incumbent in an election |
| 43% | CCS | 3 | Adds as an additional recipient, in email |
| 43% | HOLEINONE | 9 | Also known as an ace in golf |
| 43% | PLANETS | 7 | *Nonet redefined as an octet in 2006 |
| 43% | BURNED | 6 | Outed as an agent, in spy lingo |
| 43% | TARO | 4 | Tuber used as an ingredient in poi |
| 43% | SOP | 3 | Dip, as bread in gravy |