| 100% | BUNNY | 5 | Easter ___, modern legendary creature that appears on Easter |
| 53% | VAMPIRE | 7 | Modern legendary creature that is a blood-sucking monster |
| 52% | LOCHNESS | 8 | Modern legendary creature that is a sea monster: 2 wds. |
| 51% | FAIRY | 5 | Tooth ___, modern legendary creature that exchanges teeth for money |
| 49% | DEVIL | 5 | Jersey ___, modern legendary creature that is said to inhabit the Pine Barrens forest |
| 40% | DRAGONS | 7 | Legendary creatures that might breathe fire |
| 39% | YETI | 4 | Modern legendary creature supposedly found in the Himalayas |
| 39% | PREDATOR | 8 | Creature that feeds on animals it has killed |
| 39% | ONE | 3 | Number that appears on a penny |
| 39% | SEATURTLES | 10 | Water creatures that hatch on land |
| 38% | CENT | 4 | "One ___" (phrase that appears on a penny) |
| 38% | GOD | 3 | Word that appears on all US coins |
| 38% | RHEAS | 5 | Birds that appear on money from Montevideo |
| 38% | LOONS | 5 | Birds that appear on Canadian dollar coins |
| 38% | DEMENTOR | 8 | Harry Potter creature that feeds on happiness |
| 38% | EGG | 3 | Item that's dyed and hidden on Easter |
| 38% | LOON | 4 | "Crazy" bird that appears on Canadian dollar coins |
| 38% | CORROSION | 9 | Orange rust that appears on iron and steel |
| 38% | FRIGATE | 7 | Bird that appears on the flag of Kiribati |
| 38% | KOOKABURRA | 10 | Bird that appears on the Australian $20 banknote |
| 38% | LOONS | 5 | Birds that appear on Canada's $1 coins |
| 38% | RAT | 3 | Auspicious Chinese beast that appeared on January 25 |
| 38% | PIZZADRAGON | 11 | Mythical creature that feeds on Little Caesars pies? |
| 38% | MAGGOTS | 7 | Worm-like creatures that feed on the dead |
| 38% | BIRDS | 5 | Modern creatures that are technically dinosaurs |
| 38% | NENE | 4 | Creature that can walk on lava |
| 37% | MANTICORE | 9 | Legendary creature that looks like a sphinx with a spiky tail |
| 37% | EMU | 3 | Bird that appears on Australia's 50-cent coin |
| 37% | LOONS | 5 | "Crazy" birds that appear on Canada's $1 coins |
| 37% | RIPPLES | 7 | Small waves that appear on the surface of water |