| 100% | OTOOLE | 6 | Eight-time Best Actor nominee whose only Oscar was honorary |
| 52% | OTOOLE | 6 | Actor whose honorary award in 2003 was his only Oscar, despite eight nominations |
| 51% | OTOOLE | 6 | Eight-time Best Actor Oscar nominee |
| 50% | OTOOLE | 6 | Eight-time Best Actor Oscar nominee who never won |
| 45% | PETEROTOOLE | 11 | Eight-time Best Actor nominee |
| 45% | OTOOLE | 6 | Eight-time Best Actor nominee |
| 43% | SELLERS | 7 | Peter —, Best Actor in a Leading Role Oscar nominee for Being There |
| 42% | DALL | 4 | John —, Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar nominee for The Corn is Green |
| 42% | RUFFALO | 7 | Mark —, Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar nominee for The Kids Are All Right |
| 41% | MATT | 4 | & 18D Best Actor in a Leading Role Oscar nominee for Good Will Hunting and The Martian |
| 41% | ARKIN | 5 | Alan —, Best Actor in a Leading Role Oscar nominee for The Heart is a Lonely Hunter |
| 40% | RAINS | 5 | Four-time Best Supporting Actor Oscar nominee Claude |
| 39% | OTOOLE | 6 | Most-nominated Best Actor (eight times) never to win an Oscar |
| 39% | SCORSESE | 8 | Eight-time Best Director nominee who has won only once |
| 39% | ALI | 3 | Actor Mahershala whose first Oscar was for "Moonlight" |
| 37% | HULCE | 5 | "Amadeus" Best Actor Oscar nominee Tom |
| 37% | OTOOLE | 6 | Best Actor Oscar nominee for "The Lion in Winter" |
| 37% | BRADLEY | 7 | "American Sniper" Best Actor Oscar nominee Cooper |
| 37% | DAMON | 5 | Matt —, Best Actor in a Leading Role Oscar-nominee for Good Will Hunting and The Martian |
| 37% | ROBINWILLIAMS | 13 | Three-time Best Actor nominee |
| 37% | PETEROTOOLE | 11 | Seven-time Best Actor nominee |
| 37% | MAHERSHALAALI | 13 | Actor whose role in 2018's "Green Book" is the longest Best Supporting Actor-winning performance (screen time 1:06:38): 2 wds. |
| 37% | DEVPATEL | 8 | Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar nominee for Lion |
| 37% | JOSHBROLIN | 10 | Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar nominee for Milk |
| 37% | TOMHULCE | 8 | Best Actor in a Leading Role Oscar nominee for Amadeus |
| 36% | ONEAL | 5 | Ryan —, Best Actor Oscar nominee for Love Story |
| 36% | MICHAELSHANNON | 14 | Two-time Best Supporting Actor Oscar nominee who plays Nicky in 46-Across (2 wds.) |
| 36% | EDHARRIS | 8 | Best Actor in a Supporting Role Oscar nominee for Apollo 13 |