| 100% | DELPH | 5 | Fabian —, England and Everton FC midfielder and defender |
| 72% | DELPH | 5 | Fabian —, England and Manchester City FC midfielder and defender |
| 71% | DELPH | 5 | Fabian —, England and Everton midfielder/defender |
| 68% | DELPH | 5 | Fabian —, England and Manchester City FC midfielder/defender |
| 55% | DELPH | 5 | Fabian —, former Man City and Everton midfielder; in England's 2018 World Cup Finals squad |
| 53% | DELPH | 5 | Fabian —, England and Manchester City midfield footballer |
| 50% | LUIZ | 4 | David —, Brazil and Arsenal FC defender and midfielder |
| 48% | STERLING | 8 | Raheem —, England and Manchester City FC midfielder |
| 46% | CAHILL | 6 | Gary —, Chelsea FC, England and former Bolton Wanderers defender |
| 44% | LOOKMAN | 7 | Ademola —, Nigeria and Atalanta winger; formerly with Everton FC and England U21 |
| 43% | ANITA | 5 | Vurnon —, Netherlands and Leeds United FC midfielder/defender |
| 42% | LUIZ | 4 | David —, Brazil and Chelsea FC defender/midfielder |
| 41% | ASHLEYCOLE | 10 | 2001-14 England defender whose clubs included Chelsea FC, LA Galaxy and Arsenal |
| 38% | VRANCIC | 7 | Mario —, Bosnia and Herzegovina and Norwich FC midfielder |
| 37% | ODOI | 4 | Denis —, Belgium and Fulham FC defender |
| 36% | BREHME | 6 | Andreas —, Germany midfielder and defender; 1990 FIFA World Cup Final scorer |
| 36% | EDMILSON | 8 | 2000-07 Brazil midfielder and defender; 2002 FIFA World Cup Final winner |
| 35% | LALLANA | 7 | Adam —, England, Liverpool and former Southampton midfield footballer |
| 34% | SMALLING | 8 | Chris —, former England and Manchester United defender born in 1989 |
| 33% | ROCASTLE | 8 | David —, former Arsenal and Leeds United midfield footballer; 1988 England debutant |
| 33% | OTAMENDI | 8 | Nicolas —, Argentina and Manchester City FC defender |
| 33% | DELE | 4 | & 2D Everton midfielder; 2015 England debutant against Estonia |
| 32% | PLATT | 5 | David —, former England and Aston Villa midfield footballer; 1990 PFA Players' Player of the Year award winner |
| 32% | KEOWN | 5 | Martin —, former England, Everton and Arsenal footballer who retired in 2005 |
| 32% | DIOP | 4 | Issa —, West Ham United FC and France youth defender |
| 31% | LAHM | 4 | Philipp —, Germany defender and midfielder; 2014 FIFA World Cup Final winner |
| 30% | PLATT | 5 | David —, former England and Arsenal midfield footballer; 1990 PFA Players' Player of the Year award winner |
| 30% | WOOSNAM | 7 | Max —, England and Manchester City defender; 1920 Olympic men's doubles tennis gold medallist with Noel Turnbull |
| 29% | CAULKER | 7 | Steven —, Fenerbahce and Sierra Leone defender who formerly played for QPR and England |