| 100% | NICOLAS | 7 | Face/Off star who switches faces with John |
| 46% | CENA | 4 | Wrestler John who starred in 2019's "Playing With Fire" |
| 45% | JOHN | 4 | With 39-Across, "Snowpiercer" actor who starred as John Merrick in 16-Across |
| 44% | CHAZ | 4 | ___ Lamar Shepherd, "Set It Off" actor who starred in "7th Heaven" as John Hamilton |
| 43% | CAGE | 4 | Actor Nicolas who starred in Face/Off |
| 42% | ROBERTMITCHUM | 13 | "The Winds of War" actor who starred with John Wayne in "El Dorado" and in 31-Across (2 wds.) |
| 42% | DUELED | 6 | Faced off with swords |
| 41% | ELTON | 5 | John who once toured with Joel |
| 41% | MUGGER | 6 | One who makes faces |
| 40% | ATBAT | 5 | Facing off with the pitcher: 2 wds. |
| 39% | AMBERRILEY | 10 | "Glee" star who won "Dancing With the Stars" in 2017 |
| 39% | CHOWYUNFAT | 10 | Hong Kong action hero who frequently collaborated with John Woo |
| 39% | LOOK | 4 | John Travolta starrer "___ Who's Talking" |
| 38% | ERIN | 4 | Andrews who cohosts "Dancing With the Stars" |
| 38% | OSMOND | 6 | Donny who won "Dancing With the Stars" |
| 38% | TYRA | 4 | Banks who hosted "Dancing with the Stars" |
| 38% | RANDY | 5 | ___ Orton, WWE star who is associated with the Make-A-Wish foundation |
| 38% | PUNK | 4 | CM ___, WWE star who is associated with the Make-A-Wish foundation |
| 38% | DANIEL | 6 | ___ Bryan, WWE star who is associated with the Make-A-Wish foundation |
| 38% | MCENROE | 7 | John, US tennis star who won 16 Grand Slam titles |
| 38% | JUSTIN | 6 | With 32-Across, pop star who turned 18 in 2012 |
| 38% | CARSON | 6 | With 45-Across, former MTV star who hosts "The Voice" |
| 38% | WOO | 3 | John who directed "Face/Off" and "Broken Arrow" |
| 38% | RINGO | 5 | Drummer who played with John, Paul and George |
| 38% | ONO | 3 | Yoko who held "bed-ins" with John Lennon |
| 38% | NAS | 3 | Hip-hop star who feuded with Jay-Z |
| 38% | ADAM | 4 | Skater Rippon who won "Dancing With the Stars" |
| 38% | MALKOVICH | 9 | John who starred in Dangerous Liaisons |
| 38% | ELTON | 5 | John who writes with Bernie Taupin |
| 38% | ELTON | 5 | John who collaborates with Bernie Taupin |