| 100% | BELIEVE | 7 | Faithful love song by Elton, lyrics "I __ in love" |
| 60% | WANT | 4 | "I ___ Love," 2001 song by Elton John that features Robert Downey Jr. in the music video |
| 55% | FRIDAY | 6 | Song by UK rock band The Cure, __ I'm in Love |
| 55% | EVER | 4 | "If I ___ Fall In Love Again," song by Kenny Rogers |
| 53% | IREALLYLIKEYOU | 14 | 2015 hit song by 49-Across with the lyrics "But how'd we get in this position? / It's way too soon, I know this isn't love" (4 wds.) |
| 53% | HELPME | 6 | Joni Mitchell song with the lyric “I think I’m falling in love too fast” |
| 52% | LAYLA | 5 | Clapton song with the lyric “Like a fool, I fell in love with you” |
| 52% | LAYLA | 5 | Eric Clapton song with the lyric "Like a fool, I fell in love with you" |
| 50% | MUCH | 4 | "That Don't Impress Me ___," 1998 song by Shania Twain that refers to Brad Pitt in the lyrics |
| 49% | MAINSTREET | 10 | Top 40 song by 46-Across with the lyrics "I drift back in time and I find my feet" |
| 48% | BLUESKIES | 9 | Irving Berlin song with the lyrics “Noticing the days hurrying by / When you’re in love, my, how they fly” |
| 48% | CANDLE | 6 | "___ in the Wind," 1973 song by Elton John |
| 48% | CANDLE | 6 | "___ in the Wind," 1974 song by Elton John |
| 48% | DIRT | 4 | "Captain Fantastic and the Brown ___ Cowboy," 1975 album by Elton John with the hit song "We All Fall in Love Sometimes" |
| 47% | ACTION | 6 | Love __, Human League song, aka I Believe in Love |
| 46% | COAST | 5 | "Songs from the West ___," 2001 album by Elton with the Grammy-nominated song "I Want Love" |
| 45% | LET | 3 | "___ Me," a song by Elvis Presley that was featured in the film he acted in, "Love Me Tender" |
| 45% | HER | 3 | "And I Love ___," hit song by The Beatles |
| 44% | CESTSIBON | 9 | Song title followed by the lyric "Lovers say that in France" |
| 44% | ITSSO | 5 | “___ easy to fall in love” (Linda Ronstadt song lyric) |
| 44% | APARADE | 7 | What I love, in song |
| 44% | ROCKET | 6 | "___ Man," 1972 song by Elton John with an astronaut's vehicle in its title |
| 44% | HATE | 4 | "___ That I Love You," song by Rihanna featuring Ne-Yo |
| 43% | HOLD | 4 | "___ Me Closer," song by Elton John and Britney Spears that features elements from his older songs |
| 43% | YOU | 3 | "Can ___ Feel the Love Tonight," 1994 song by Elton John covered by S Club 7 |
| 43% | WIND | 4 | "Candle in the ___," song by Elton John that was written in honor of Marilyn Monroe |
| 43% | LAYLA | 5 | Song with the line "Like a fool, I fell in love with you" |
| 43% | CRAZY | 5 | "___ in Love," a hit song by Beyonce featuring her husband Jay-Z |
| 43% | POKERFACE | 9 | Hit song by 42-Across with the lyrics "I wanna hold 'em like they do in Texas, please" (2 wds.) |
| 43% | EVA | 3 | "Me" in the Oscar-winning song "You Must Love Me" |