| 100% | LEAVES | 6 | Fall's colorful staple that would butter you up with "I keep falling for you!" |
| 72% | CORN | 4 | Fall staple that would butter you up with "I'm all ears for you!" |
| 66% | JACK | 4 | ___ o'lantern, fall staple that would butter you up with "You make me light up!" |
| 64% | CROW | 4 | Word after "scare" to refer to a fall staple that would butter you up with "You got me standing tall!" |
| 47% | BONFIRE | 7 | Cozy fall night favorite that would warm you up with "I feel a spark between us!" |
| 33% | DECAF | 5 | Coffee that won't keep you up, for short |
| 33% | DECAF | 5 | Coffee that probably won't keep you up, for short |
| 33% | SWEATER | 7 | Autumn attire that would sweet-talk you with "You make me feel warm" |
| 31% | RAKE | 4 | Long-handled tool that a gardener would use for cleaning up leaves in the fall |
| 31% | WHISK | 5 | Kitchen essential that you would use to whip up your eggs just right for your breakfast |
| 31% | FATHERTIME | 10 | "___? That's when you're hanging out with me" |
| 30% | CAN | 3 | Container with a spout, that a gardener would use for keeping flowers hydrated |
| 30% | APPLAUSE | 8 | Hit song by 43-Across with the lyrics "Live for the way that you cheer and scream for me" |
| 30% | APPLAUSE | 8 | Hit song by 42-Across with the lyrics "Live for the way that you cheer and scream for me" |
| 29% | SNL | 3 | Show with a "What's Up With That?" segment, for short |
| 29% | CUES | 4 | Gizmos that will help you with your banking |
| 29% | TAXMAN | 6 | Beatles song with the lyric "There's one for you, nineteen for me" |
| 29% | EYE | 3 | "Keep an ___ on that while I'm away, will you?" |
| 28% | UMNO | 4 | "Did you really think I'd go for that?" |
| 28% | NICETRY | 7 | “As if I’d fall for that!” |
| 28% | ESPRESSO | 8 | Shot that keeps you up |
| 28% | CSI | 3 | Forensics-based drama that's wrapping up with a two-hour finale this fall |
| 28% | BODYGUARD | 9 | The __, film with Whitney's I Will Always Love You |
| 28% | ALLOWME | 7 | "May I do that for you?" |
| 28% | LET | 3 | "Please, ___ me get that for you" |
| 28% | BOOTS | 5 | Footwear that keeps you warm during a nippy fall morning or Dora's monkey friend |
| 28% | REMBRANDTS | 10 | Band that sang the "Friends" theme song "I'll Be There for You," with "the" |
| 28% | SODA | 4 | Fizzy drink that will keep you cool during a road trip |
| 28% | ABCS | 4 | Song that ends "Next time won't you sing with me" |
| 28% | DECAF | 5 | Joe that won't keep you up |