| 100% | BEARD | 5 | Feature of five U.S. Presidents |
| 95% | BEARD | 5 | Feature of five U.S. presidents from Lincoln to Harrison |
| 76% | YALE | 4 | Alma mater of five U.S. presidents |
| 75% | EMPIRESTATE | 11 | Birthplace of five U.S. presidents, with "the" |
| 60% | ALMAMATER | 9 | *Yale, for five U.S. presidents |
| 60% | ALMAMATER | 9 | Yale, for five U.S. presidents |
| 58% | YALE | 4 | Alma mater for five U.S. presidents |
| 57% | OHIO | 4 | State where five U.S. presidents are buried |
| 56% | ELKS | 4 | Order whose members have included five U.S. presidents |
| 55% | ROTUNDAS | 8 | Features of the U.S. Capitol and Rome's Pantheon |
| 55% | NRA | 3 | Org. of which U. S. Grant was once president |
| 55% | OHIO | 4 | Birthplace of seven U.S. presidents |
| 55% | VIRGINIA | 8 | Birthplace of eight U.S. presidents |
| 54% | WASHINGTONSTATE | 15 | Locale of five major U.S. volcanoes |
| 53% | HARRYSTRUMAN | 12 | Former U.S. president on five U.S. commemorative postage stamps who was appointed postmaster of Grandview, Missouri (3 wds.) |
| 53% | ELKS | 4 | Group to which five U.S. presidents have belonged, from Harding to Ford |
| 52% | SON | 3 | Ending of eight U.S. presidents' names |
| 52% | OBAMA | 5 | U.S. president who was also president of the Harvard Law Review |
| 52% | NIXON | 5 | U.S. president who becomes the president of future Earth on "Futurama" |
| 52% | OBAMA | 5 | U.S. president who was once president of the Harvard Law Review |
| 51% | TAFT | 4 | U.S. President who later became Chief Justice of the Supreme Court |
| 51% | TRUMAN | 6 | Harry S —, president of the US from 1945-53 |
| 51% | GRANT | 5 | Ulysses S —, president of the US from 1869-77 |
| 51% | PENNY | 5 | First U.S. coin to feature a president |
| 51% | SIX | 3 | Number of U.S. presidents named James |
| 51% | GOP | 3 | 11 U.S. presidents of the 20th century belonged to it |
| 50% | SEVEN | 5 | Number of U.S. presidents born in Ohio |
| 50% | ATTORNEY | 8 | Any one of 25 U.S. presidents |
| 50% | JAMES | 5 | First name of six U.S. presidents |
| 50% | ANDREW | 6 | First name of two U.S. presidents |