| 100% | LOVE | 4 | First-sight phenomenon |
| 74% | LOVE | 4 | ___ at first sight |
| 73% | BEACH | 5 | Castaway's first sight |
| 73% | FACIE | 5 | Prima __: at first sight |
| 71% | VAL | 3 | "At First Sight" Kilmer of |
| 71% | VAL | 3 | Kilmer of "At First Sight" |
| 71% | VAL | 3 | "At First Sight" star Kilmer |
| 71% | MARRIEDAT | 9 | Reality TV show, __ First Sight |
| 71% | CERES | 5 | Asteroid first sighted in 1801 |
| 69% | HEARTSURGE | 10 | Result of love at first sight? |
| 69% | ATA | 3 | ___ glance (upon first sight): 2 wds. |
| 67% | CUPIDSARROWS | 12 | They lead to love at first sight |
| 67% | NEAPTIDE | 8 | First or third quarter phenomenon |
| 66% | FELL | 4 | "I ___ for her at the very first sight" |
| 66% | MARRIED | 7 | __ at First Sight; TV series with instant wedding |
| 66% | MARRIED | 7 | Reality show where couples wed, __ At First Sight |
| 64% | IFELL | 5 | "___ in love with him at first sight...": 2 wds. |
| 63% | MADAGASCAR | 10 | First husband (rev.) + Road sign + Road sight |
| 62% | EARTHRISE | 9 | Natural phenomenon first witnessed in 1968 |
| 60% | SONIA | 5 | ___ and Nick, "Married at First Sight" couple who recently got divorced |
| 59% | ALTAR | 5 | Where a "Married at First Sight" contestant meets his or her mate |
| 58% | OASIS | 5 | Desert sight (seems like a mirage, at first) |
| 55% | OTIS | 4 | "Married at First Sight" star Jamie who delivered a baby daughter on August 22 |
| 55% | GRAYHOLE | 8 | Outer space phenomenon photographed for the first time in 2019 |
| 53% | HOLE | 4 | Black ___ (space phenomenon whose first ever image was captured in 2019) |
| 52% | DAYTIMEMEAWARDS | 15 | Prizes won by Acadia National Park for the first sight of sunrise in the U.S.? |
| 50% | DAYBREAK | 8 | First light ... or a phenomenon suggested by this puzzle's seven sets of circled letters? |
| 48% | LOLITA | 6 | 1955 novel with the line "It was love at first sight, at last sight, at ever and ever sight" |
| 46% | BICYCLETHIEVES | 14 | Vittorio De Sica movie that topped Sight & Sound’s first greatest-films poll, in 1952 |
| 43% | REDTIDE | 7 | Recurring marine phenomenon |