| 100% | WARWICK | 7 | First captain of the QE2: William Eldon __ |
| 51% | ROYKENT | 7 | Captain of the team in Ted Lasso's first season |
| 46% | NORMANDY | 8 | William the Conqueror's first title, Duke of __ |
| 43% | QUEEG | 5 | Captain of the Caine |
| 43% | AHAB | 4 | Captain of the Pequod |
| 43% | NEMO | 4 | Captain of the Nautilus |
| 43% | JASON | 5 | Captain of the Argo |
| 43% | NEMO | 4 | Captain of the "Nautilus" |
| 43% | MIAS | 4 | Lucien —, captain of the France rugby union team that won the Five Nations outright for the first time in 1959 |
| 42% | KINGJOHN | 8 | The Life and Death of —, stage play by William Shakespeare first published in 1623 |
| 42% | DAGAMA | 6 | Captain of the Sáo Gabriel |
| 42% | HUDSON | 6 | Captain of the Half Moon |
| 42% | FRANCISDRAKE | 12 | Captain of the ''Golden Hind'' |
| 42% | DRAKE | 5 | Captain of the Golden Hind |
| 42% | KIDD | 4 | Captain of the Adventure Galley |
| 42% | ALPHANERD | 9 | Captain of the mathletes, stereotypically |
| 42% | SOLO | 4 | Captain of the Millenium Falcon, Han ___ |
| 41% | MORPHEUS | 8 | Captain of the Nebuchadnezzar, in "The Matrix" |
| 41% | HANSOLO | 7 | Captain of the "Millennium Falcon" (2 wds.) |
| 41% | AHAB | 4 | Captain of the Pequod, in "Moby-Dick" |
| 41% | BLIGH | 5 | Captain of the HMS Bounty in 1789 |
| 41% | PICARD | 6 | A captain of the Enterprise |
| 41% | AHAB | 4 | Obsessed captain of the Pequod |
| 41% | AHAB | 4 | Fictional captain of the Pequod |
| 41% | NEMO | 4 | Fictional captain of the Nautilus |
| 41% | ETON | 4 | School where Prince William was captain of the swimming team |
| 40% | HANSOLO | 7 | Captain of the Millennium Falcon in Star Wars |
| 40% | BRANNIGAN | 9 | Zapp __, captain of the starship Nimbus |
| 40% | OVECHKIN | 8 | Alexander __, captain of the Washington Capitals |
| 40% | ASHE | 4 | Davis Cup captain of the 1980s |