| 100% | ALITO | 5 | First in an alphabetical list of current Supreme Court Justices |
| 43% | ALITO | 5 | First justice alphabetically in the history of the Supreme Court |
| 42% | RBG | 3 | Supreme Court Justice depicted in "On the Basis of Sex," familiarly |
| 42% | BOX | 3 | Enclosure ... and an alphabetical listing of letters not appearing elsewhere in this puzzle's answer |
| 41% | RBG | 3 | Supreme Court Justice played by Felicity Jones in "On the Basis of Sex," familiarly |
| 40% | ELENAKAGAN | 10 | Supreme Court justice since 2010 and winner of a National Merit Scholarship in 1977: 2 wds. |
| 40% | JOHNROBERTS | 11 | First Supreme Court justice confirmed in the 21st century (2005): 2 wds. |
| 40% | YALE | 4 | Alma mater of four current Supreme Court justices |
| 38% | FEMALE | 6 | Like four current Supreme Court justices |
| 37% | BREYER | 6 | Supreme Court Justice appointed in 1994 |
| 36% | SANDRA | 6 | First name of the first female Supreme Court justice |
| 36% | GLOSSARY | 8 | Alphabetical list of terms in a text |
| 36% | IOWA | 4 | It follows Indiana on an alphabetical list of US states |
| 36% | BREYER | 6 | Supreme Court Justice Stephen who retired in 2022 |
| 35% | JOHNROBERTS | 11 | Supreme Court justice who swore in Barack Obama: 2 wds. |
| 35% | NINE | 4 | Number of US Supreme Court justices |
| 34% | TAFT | 4 | President who became Chief Justice of the Supreme Court in 1921 |
| 34% | OCONNOR | 7 | First female Supreme Court Justice |
| 34% | STEVENS | 7 | Former Supreme Court justice often seen in a bow tie |
| 34% | ALITO | 5 | First Supreme Court justice alphabetically, past or present |
| 34% | HUGOBLACK | 9 | Supreme Court justice known for a literalist interpretation of the Bill of Rights |
| 33% | LOUISBRANDEIS | 13 | First Jewish Supreme Court justice: 2 wds. |
| 33% | OCONNOR | 7 | First female Supreme Court justice Sandra Day ___ |
| 33% | OCONNOR | 7 | First female Supreme Court justice, Sandra Day ___ |
| 33% | DRED | 4 | Scott in an 1857 Supreme Court case |
| 33% | RBG | 3 | Notorious initials of famed Supreme Court justice |
| 33% | NINE | 4 | Number of Supreme Court justices |
| 33% | ABE | 3 | Supreme Court Justice Fortas, who wrote the majority opinion in Tinker v. Des Moines |
| 33% | SAMUELALITO | 11 | Second Supreme Court justice confirmed in the 21st century (2006): 2 wds. |