| 100% | COD | 3 | Fish commonly caught in the Atlantic Ocean |
| 68% | LAKETROUT | 9 | Fish commonly caught in the Upper Midwest |
| 55% | AZORES | 6 | Portuguese island group in the Atlantic Ocean |
| 54% | BERMUDA | 7 | Ship-swallowing triangle in the Atlantic Ocean |
| 54% | FALKLAND | 8 | __ Islands; Islas Malvinas in the Atlantic Ocean |
| 52% | CODFISH | 7 | Catch in the North Atlantic |
| 51% | SHAD | 4 | Fish usually caught in the winter |
| 49% | OCEANPERCH | 10 | Fish caught in the Pacific |
| 49% | RIVERTROUT | 10 | Fish caught in the Mississippi |
| 49% | HUDSONBAY | 9 | Inland arm of the Atlantic Ocean in Canada |
| 48% | MARY | 4 | ___ Celeste, abandoned ship that was found lost in the Atlantic Ocean in 1872 |
| 47% | ALBEMARLE | 9 | & 18D Inlet of the Atlantic Ocean in NE North Carolina |
| 47% | CARP | 4 | Freshwater fish often caught in the "Animal Crossing" games |
| 46% | CODLING | 7 | Young fish in the Atlantic |
| 46% | BANTRYBAY | 9 | Inlet of the Atlantic Ocean in Cork, Republic of Ireland, housing Whiddy Island |
| 45% | COD | 3 | The fish in fish and chips, commonly |
| 45% | BANTRY | 6 | — Bay, inlet of the Atlantic Ocean in Cork, Republic of Ireland, housing Whiddy Island |
| 44% | GUANABARA | 9 | — Bay, deep inlet of the Atlantic Ocean in Brazil upon which Rio de Janeiro stands |
| 44% | PELICAN | 7 | Ocean bird that catches fish in its throat pouch |
| 43% | HADDOCK | 7 | Fish in N. Atlantic ocean; black lateral line |
| 42% | ASCENSION | 9 | — Island, body of land in the South Atlantic Ocean north-west of St Helena |
| 42% | ACT | 3 | Caught in the ___ |
| 42% | ACT | 3 | Caught in the __ |
| 42% | ROSEFISH | 8 | Food fish of the southeast Atlantic and western Indian Oceans |
| 42% | ASCENSION | 9 | — Island, volcanic body of land in the South Atlantic Ocean north-west of St Helena |
| 41% | SEEN | 4 | Caught in the act |
| 41% | NAILED | 6 | Caught in the act |
| 41% | BUSTED | 6 | Caught in the act |
| 41% | ACT | 3 | Caught in the ___ (redhanded) |