| 100% | LIVEONE | 7 | Fish that's being reeled in |
| 63% | EEL | 3 | Fish that may be caught in a cage |
| 61% | EELS | 4 | Fish that are found in some sushi dishes |
| 60% | EELS | 4 | Snakelike fish that are caught in pots |
| 59% | EELS | 4 | Snakelike fish that are abundant in Lake Hamana |
| 58% | EEL | 3 | Snaky fish that can be caught in a pot |
| 58% | NEMO | 4 | Fish that Marlin and Dory are looking for in a 2003 movie |
| 57% | EEL | 3 | Fish that's grilled in hitsumabushi |
| 57% | NEMO | 4 | Fish that Marlin and Dory are looking for, in a 2003 Pixar film |
| 57% | PIRANHA | 7 | Deadly fish that is found in tanks in a Bond film |
| 56% | COD | 3 | Fish that's caught in New England |
| 56% | ANCHOVIES | 9 | Small fish that are sometimes used in Caesar dressing or on pizza |
| 55% | TUNA | 4 | Fish that's often advertised as being "dolphin-free" |
| 55% | TUNA | 4 | Fish that's often described as being "dolphin-safe" |
| 55% | KOI | 3 | Colorful Japanese fish that might be in a pond |
| 55% | KOI | 3 | Fish that's a homophone for "love" in Japanese |
| 54% | KOI | 3 | Colorful Japanese fish that might be in a backyard pond |
| 54% | TUNA | 4 | Fish that's often used in sandwiches |
| 53% | EEL | 3 | Fish that's never served raw because its blood is poisonous |
| 53% | COD | 3 | Atlantic fish that's popular in fish and chips |
| 53% | CATCH | 5 | Fish that's no longer in the sea |
| 53% | EEL | 3 | Fish that's an ingredient in some sushi |
| 53% | EEL | 3 | Fish that's rarely found in home aquariums |
| 53% | SARDINE | 7 | Fish that's packed tightly in a can |
| 53% | COD | 3 | Fish that's often caught in New England |
| 53% | ROD | 3 | Reel's partner in fishing |
| 53% | ROD | 3 | Reel's partner, in fishing |
| 52% | COD | 3 | Type of fish that's often in fish and chips |
| 52% | NOTCH | 5 | Marking that's been scratched in wood |
| 51% | SNAPPER | 7 | Fish that can be red, sounds like it's a biter |