| 100% | EELS | 4 | Fish that spawn in the Sargasso Sea |
| 59% | CATCH | 5 | Fish that's no longer in the sea |
| 54% | SALMON | 6 | Fish that spawns in fresh water |
| 53% | EEL | 3 | Spawner in the Sargasso Sea |
| 53% | BERMUDA | 7 | Island in the sargasso sea |
| 53% | ROE | 3 | Spawn in the sea |
| 51% | LACKOFEELING | 12 | What pollution in the Sargasso Sea may lead to? |
| 50% | ELVER | 5 | Young fish that has migrated from the Sargasso Sea |
| 49% | EEL | 3 | Creature that may travel to the Sargasso Sea to spawn and lay eggs |
| 47% | BAHAMUT | 7 | Fish that supports the Earth in Arabian mythology |
| 46% | EEL | 3 | Fish that became the first coconut tree, in Samoan myth |
| 45% | STARGAZER | 9 | Astrologer; a fish that lives and hides in warm seas |
| 45% | POETICA | 7 | "Ars ___" (Horace work that spawned the phrase in medias res) |
| 45% | MARLIN | 6 | Fish in "The Old Man and the Sea" |
| 44% | ATLANTIC | 8 | Ocean that contains the Sargasso Sea |
| 44% | PERIL | 5 | "For those in ___ on the sea" |
| 44% | PERIL | 5 | "For those in ___ on the sea..." (danger) |
| 43% | OPAH | 4 | Fish in the family Lampridae that's unrelated to the lamprey |
| 42% | BLUE | 4 | Shade that the sky and the sea have in common |
| 42% | DELMAR | 6 | Surname that means “of the sea” in Spanish |
| 42% | SEINE | 5 | Big fishing net that hangs in the water |
| 41% | DON | 3 | River that rises in the Cairngorm Mountains before flowing east to the North Sea |
| 41% | GIANTSQUID | 10 | Creature that attacked the Nautilus in "Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea" |
| 41% | MARLIN | 6 | Fish caught by Santiago in "The Old Man and the Sea" |
| 40% | ODER | 4 | River in Central Europe that ends in the Baltic Sea |
| 40% | GRUNION | 7 | Fish that spawns at high tide |
| 40% | EELER | 5 | Fisherman in the Sargasso |
| 40% | PELICAN | 7 | Large aquatic bird that stores fish in a pouch below the lower mandible |
| 39% | EELS | 4 | Denizens of the Sargasso Sea |
| 39% | CRAB | 4 | Sea creature that's featured in the zodiac |