| 100% | BOGGS | 5 | Five-time A.L. batting champion |
| 83% | BOGGS | 5 | Five-time A.L. batting champ |
| 78% | BOGGS | 5 | Wade who was five-time A.L. batting champ |
| 73% | OLIVA | 5 | Three-time A.L. batting champion Tony |
| 70% | CAREW | 5 | Slugger Rod who was the A.L. batting champion seven times between 1969 and 1978 |
| 60% | CAREW | 5 | Seven-time A.L. batting champ |
| 60% | OLIVA | 5 | Three-time A.L. batting champ |
| 60% | BRETT | 5 | Three-time A.L. batting champ |
| 60% | ALLAH | 5 | He's prayed to five times a day |
| 59% | CAREW | 5 | Seven-time A.L. batting champ Rod |
| 59% | CAREW | 5 | Seven-time A.L. batting champ Rod ___ |
| 59% | OLIVA | 5 | Three-time A.L. batting champ Tony |
| 59% | VENUSWILLIAMS | 13 | Five-time Wimbledon champion whose name contains a planet (2 wds.) |
| 58% | IDO | 3 | Repeated five times, a song by 1-Across |
| 57% | PRAYERMAT | 9 | Platform on which millions submit up to five times a day |
| 57% | DOO | 3 | When sung five times, a 1974 Rolling Stones hit |
| 57% | DOO | 3 | When said five times, a 1974 Rolling Stones hit |
| 55% | CANDYMAN | 8 | Name not to say five times into a mirror |
| 53% | TOKILL | 6 | A Time __; crime drama starring Samuel L Jackson |
| 52% | SIRI | 4 | "Hey, ___, set a timer for five minutes" |
| 50% | AVILA | 5 | 1954 A.L. batting champ |
| 50% | ALKALINE | 8 | 1955 A.L. batting champ |
| 50% | GOOSEGOSLIN | 11 | 1928 A.L. batting champ |
| 50% | BORG | 4 | Five-time Wimbledon champion |
| 50% | OILERS | 6 | Five-time Stanley Cup champions |
| 49% | CAREW | 5 | Rod who was a seven-time A.L. batting champ |
| 49% | RICHARDS | 8 | Gordon —, British flat racing Champion Jockey a record 26 times |
| 49% | WRINKLEIN | 9 | Madeleine L'Engle's children's sci-fi, A __ Time |
| 49% | BRETT | 5 | A.L. batting champ in three different decades |
| 49% | BILL | 4 | ___ Buckner, one time National League batting champion who played as the first baseman for five MLB teams and passed away in 2019 |