| 100% | ISAO | 4 | Five-time Japan Senior Open winner ___ Aoki |
| 81% | ISAO | 4 | Five-time Japan Senior Open champion ___ Aoki |
| 45% | COLIN | 5 | 2014 U.S. Senior Open winner Montgomerie |
| 45% | SBAMPRAS | 8 | Five-time U.S. Open winner |
| 45% | GRAF | 4 | Five-time U.S. Open winner |
| 45% | TOM | 3 | With 1-Down, five-time winner of the British Open |
| 42% | BRAID | 5 | James —, Scottish golfer, five-times winner of The Open Championship, who died in 1950 |
| 39% | TOMWATSON | 9 | Winner of five British Opens between 1975 and 1983 |
| 38% | BORG | 4 | Winner of Wimbledon five consecutive times between Ashe and McEnroe |
| 38% | RAZZANO | 7 | Virginie —, 2007 Japan Open singles tennis tournament winner |
| 37% | WATSON | 6 | Five-time British Open champ |
| 37% | GRAF | 4 | Five-time US Open champ |
| 37% | UCLA | 4 | Five-time Rose Bowl winner |
| 37% | ARCARO | 6 | Five-time Kentucky Derby winner |
| 36% | HARTACK | 7 | Five-time Kentucky Derby winner Bill |
| 36% | LUIS | 4 | Five-time Latin Grammy winner Fonsi |
| 35% | DATE | 4 | Kimiko —, 1992-94 and 1996 Japan Open singles tennis tournament winner |
| 35% | GRAF | 4 | Five-time US Open tennis champ Steffi |
| 35% | KELSO | 5 | Five-time Jockey Club Gold Cup winner |
| 35% | UCLA | 4 | Five-time Rose Bowl winner, for short |
| 35% | GRAF | 4 | Five-time U.S. Open champ |
| 35% | ARCARO | 6 | Five-time Derby winner |
| 35% | TYNEDALY | 8 | Five-time Emmy winner |
| 35% | USHER | 5 | Five-time Grammy winner |
| 34% | BRASIL | 6 | Five-time winner of the Copa do Mundo |
| 34% | GRAF | 4 | Five-time U.S. Open champ Steffi |
| 34% | ESPOSITO | 8 | Five-time Art Ross Trophy winner |
| 34% | ESA | 3 | ___ Tikkanen, five-time Stanley Cup winner |
| 34% | SELES | 5 | Two-time U.S. Open winner |
| 34% | SAMPRAS | 7 | Three-time U.S. Open winner |